Sister, Shut Up!

But this kind of contradiction can only be gradually discovered through further thinking.

At this point, Su Huai porridge looked at Jiang Miao with sparkling eyes, never expecting that the junior could make a beautiful counterattack under such circumstances.

xiaoshuting.la

But when he thought that he had promised to reward him first, which made his junior perform so exceptionally, Su Huai Porridge couldn't help but blush and spat.

And after being dismantled by Jiang Miao in this way, even Wang Xin couldn't help frowning, wasting two or three seconds at once.

But after all, he responded in a timely manner, and immediately got up to respond: "We said that because of relatively short-sighted reasons, young people are more likely to choose to sell the future time they think is redundant, even if the price is relatively low."

"Then ask your question according to your third debate question. Graduates earn 5000 yuan a month. Do you think graduates have to sell for a month? What price is acceptable to young people?" Jiang Miao continued to ask, Hold on tight to this point.

"It could be [-] or [-]. The exact price is not necessarily accurate, but at least it will be higher than the salary." Wang Xin said, frowning, feeling that the rhythm was a bit led away.

"Okay, let's go back to the original question." Jiang Miao smiled and asked, "At such a price, if a large number of young people choose to sell their time to lie down and enjoy themselves according to what you said in the first argument, then in The world is gradually falling into a labor shortage, how can various industrial chains continue to operate?"

"Will the sudden shortage of a large number of labor force lead to a sudden reduction in the output of various materials?"

"Will the reduction in production lead to an increase in prices and a depreciation of the currency?"

"Will it eventually lead to the depreciation of the value of time, so that capital must make the price of time slightly lower than wages in order to restore a large number of lost labor?"

"And when the price of time is lower than wages, who is willing to sell time?"

The series of pursuits were deafening, causing the audience in the audience to fall into a state of sluggishness for a short time.

And Lin Jingwen and Lu Yu also became interested, and suddenly found that Zhengfang seemed to have hope of a comeback.

But it has to be said that Wang Xin's psychological quality is still strong.

When the three teammates were completely misfired, they still got up and caught some loopholes in Jiang Miao's remarks:

"According to what you said, when the price of time falls below wages, most young people will choose not to sell their time. So what is the reason for your support of this technology?"

"Since it will not be sold in the end, isn't this technology just taking off your pants and farting?"

"Since that's the case, it's better not to support it in the first place."

"No." Jiang Miao got up and shook his head, smiling, "This is where the value of this technology lies."

"Because the price of time will eventually fall back to a normal range, reducing most people's desire to sell time, it will give young people who need funds to develop themselves new opportunities."

"Because the jobs that most people can get will never be the ones they like or even just interested in."

"And this technology gives young people who pursue their ideals a chance to develop, so that they don't have to spend time in mediocre jobs and have funds to improve themselves."

"Wrong." Wang Zi immediately retorted, "Just for this seemingly beautiful vision, time must be allowed to enter the free market. According to the laws of capital, the time market will eventually be monopolized by capital."

"At that time, those who control the capital will control eternal life, and the young people who pursue their ideals mentioned in your mouth are just puppets in the hands of capital. They are manipulated by their ideals and are willing to give their time. The eternal building block of capital."

"The capitalists will truly stand high above the world, looking down on the world, eternally unchanged, hundreds of years, thousands of years, tens of thousands of years, hundreds of millions of ants provide time, so that the people at the top of the pyramid will never decay. Is this the world you want to see? "

"It's time for the opposing side." The host said.

Wang Zi stopped speaking immediately. Fortunately, his rebuttal was sufficient, at least the situation was not completely reversed by the affirmative.

At this time, the affirmative only had five seconds left. Jiang Miao knew that he had nothing to say in this time, so he stood up and said, "I will elaborate on the objection's question in the conclusion."

"It's square time."

"It's so handsome, Jiang Miao is so handsome!" In the auditorium, a girl suppressed her voice and said excitedly in the ear of her best friend.

"Wang Zi is also very good. If I were to be on the court, Jiang Miao would probably have been confused."

Many people thought it was very exciting. They didn't think the debate was very interesting before, but this time the topic of the debate was very interesting. The confrontation between the two debaters also went back and forth, and there was no one-sided situation that everyone thought.

And this situation was somewhat beyond Lu Yu and Lin Jingwen's expectations.

Although they are not very professional debaters, they are still members of the school debate team, and each is the captain and vice-captain of the debate team of their own college.

Therefore, the research on debate must be much better than that of freshmen.

As far as their first reaction when they saw the debate topic, it was actually that the opposing side would win.

Because once time is monetized in the free market, capital will inevitably lead to the monopoly of time.

This is a dead end.

In the free debate session, in most of the previous offenses and defenses, the affirmative's offense was very good, capturing the loopholes in the first and second arguments of the opposing party and outputting madly.

But in the end, the deeper capital factor was pointed out by Wang Zinc, and Zhengfang was pushed to the edge of the cliff all of a sudden.

Next, it is the closing time for the four debates of the pros and cons.

Since the affirmative party speaks first at the opening, the concluding argument is concluded by the opposing party first.

"The opposing side concludes the argument for 3 minutes, and the opposing side is invited to argue four times."

Before the host finished speaking, Wang Zi had already got up, his expression was still calm, but his fingers pinching the paper were much harder than usual.

141. This time it's not about collecting materials

Generally speaking, after the free debate is over, the judges basically already have a conclusion in their minds.

Especially for the freshman competition, both sides are not professional debaters, and the final four debates are more just for sorting out and summarizing.

Debate is a very intense mental exercise.

During the debate, the debater's thinking will be highly tense. If there is no long-term exercise and adaptation, most people will fall into a situation of slow reaction in the fierce confrontation.

It's like arguing with someone. Often after the quarrel is over, when I go home and lie on the bed, I suddenly recall the various episodes of the quarrel, and feel that if I swear back like this at that time, the power may be a little stronger.

So I was annoyed why I was choked up at the time, if only when I quarreled, I could be as majestic as I imagined now.

But in the fierce collision of opinions, few people can keep their brains running at high speed in the constantly exposed loopholes.

Most people only gradually reacted after finishing the debate, thinking that they should have responded in the same way before, and responded to questions in this way.

On the spot, it is already not easy to ensure that the logic is stable and clear.

After Wang Zi got up, he made some revisions according to the conclusion draft he had prepared in advance and according to the confrontation on the field, and then began to speak.

Compared with the extensive summarization and extension of the three arguments of the opposing party in the initial concluding defense draft, Wang Zinc’s concluding argument at this time only briefly summed up the three arguments, and spent more time on the alienation of capital from time transactions.

It is roughly an expanded version of Wang Zinc's last speech in the previous free debate.

"So to sum it up, in addition to our initial three arguments, what is based on these three arguments is that capital uses time trading to cause a deeper alienation of people."

"This has three serious consequences."

"First, capital will monopolize time trading, forming a huge time repository, and a large amount of time will be in the hands of capital."

"Second, the middle and low-level people will be further exploited by capital, from the exploitation of labor force to the exploitation of life time."

"Third, capitalists who control capital will gain unlimited lives and form a complete monopoly on rights in the true sense."

"Therefore, we firmly believe that the new technology of free trading life time should not be supported."

At this point, the 3 minutes of the opposing side's closing argument ended, and Wang Zi's tense body finally relaxed a little. After bowing slightly to the audience, he sat back in his seat.

But even after finishing his speech, Wang Zi still couldn't relax completely, and his eyes immediately fell on Jiang Miao who was opposite.

But at this moment, Jiang Miao's heartbeat was already beating like a drum. Taking advantage of Wang Xin's three minutes of fighting with each other, Jiang Miao has been writing hard on the manuscript paper.

While listening to the content of Wang Zi's conclusion and debate, he checked for omissions and filled in the gaps, while improving the logic chain of the affirmative.

Although he was naturally against the side in his heart, he was right now after all, and a sweet reward from his senior was waiting for him.

He couldn't help but start a brainstorm in his mind.

For debaters who think they are professional, it is a basic operation to stand on a position that they do not agree with in their hearts, and still be able to stably output their own views.

Although Jiang Miao is not a professional debater, but under the temptation of her senior sister, she has to work hard to become more professional.

"Thank you for the wonderful speech of the opposing party's four debates. Next, I invite the affirmative party's four debates to conduct the final closing debate, and the time is 3 minutes."

As soon as the host finished speaking, everyone's eyes immediately focused on Jiang Miao.

To be honest, even though the affirmative party attacked fiercely in the free debate session just now, it was still difficult for the affirmative party to change the audience's views under the defense of the opposing party, especially Wang Zinc.

Faced with this kind of brain hole problem, most people tend to subconsciously tend to be conservative once they are reminded of various dire risks.

Not to mention that Wang Zi, who was on the opposing side, was even more sublimated in his closing argument, raising the harmfulness of time trading to the common destiny of the world.

If even the time is lost, so that the rich can be eternally above the top, this is obviously not what everyone wants to see.

However, in the eyes of the three judges, the opposing side already had an inherent advantage, but in the free debate session, they were overwhelmed by the affirmative, leaving only room for defense and counterattack.

This is clearly a mistake by the opposing side.

Moreover, Jiang Miao cleverly pointed out the loopholes in the first two arguments of the opposing side, which can be said to have been almost dismantled.

It's just that Wang Zi still took advantage of the innate advantages of the opposing side to bring the situation back on track, and stuck the opposing side's arguments into the pain points of the positive side's position.

Right now, the stage repertoire seems to have come to an end.

Jiang Miao stood up, behind him was the cliff of defeat.

He took a deep breath, glanced at Su Huai Porridge in the audience, and saw that the senior sister was clenching her fists to cheer him on, Jiang Miao couldn't help but smile.

In the next second, the timer on the screen starts to move, and the 3-minute countdown begins.

The eyes of everyone in the audience gathered together, like a spotlight with no dead ends, illuminating the protagonists on the stage.

Jiang Miao put down the manuscript paper in her hand and raised three fingers.

"Next, I will summarize three points."

In the concise and concise opening, Jiang Miao didn't intend to waste time, and said directly.

"First, cut in from the perspective of social operation."

"Once the transaction price for one month is much higher than the average monthly income of individuals, it is bound to cause a large number of young laborers to flee as the opposing debater said."

"In this way, labor-intensive industries will be the first to suffer a heavy blow, including mining, forestry and various related manufacturing industries, and the scope of impact will be comprehensive."

"You must know that capital and capital are not a community of interests. For example, the high-speed rail in the United States has never been built, because the capital interest groups of airports and highways are resisting behind it."

"Similarly, once the time trading market has a strong impact on the labor-intensive market, it will inevitably lead to a forced drop in the price of time, prompting the return of labor, otherwise the market will fall into a vicious cycle of material shortage and inflation."

"That's why I asserted that the price of time must not be high, and it will be slightly lower than the normal average monthly income, so as to ensure that the basic market of labor will not collapse."

Having said that, Jiang Miao paused, indicating that his first point was over.

The two judges Lin Jingwen and Lu Yu held pens and recorded the complete logic chain shown by Jiang Miao.