Subverted This is the Emperor Chat Group

"Without Han Xin, wouldn't Liu Bang be able to win?"

"That's pure bullshit!"

"Without Han Xin, the Chu-Han War will still be fought well, and Liu Bang will still be the final victor. This general trend will never change!"

"Han Xin's effect on Liu Bang is not as great as you think."

"This is just touted by later generations."

Chen Tong's words immediately caused an uproar. Even the professors' eyes widened at the moment, and they couldn't believe what they heard.

Chen Tong is denying all viewpoints.

Shi Yi laughed crazily, looking at Chen Tong as if looking at a fool, and said sarcastically:

"You actually said that Han Xin was useless in the Chu-Han war?"

"Is there something wrong with your brain?"

"Let's not talk about anything else, let's just say that after the battle of Xingyang, Liu Bang was defeated by Xiang Yu. He only took the coachman and ran to Han Xin to borrow troops."

"If Han Xin didn't give the soldiers to Liu Bang, wouldn't Liu Bang die?"

"Isn't that useful?"

Shi Yi's eyes were full of sneers, like a fox who stole a chicken.

And the parents at this moment also had weird eyes. If they hadn't experienced too much worldly wisdom and decided to stand on Chen Tong's side, maybe they would point at Chen Tong's nose and curse at this moment.

But the suspicion in their eyes became more and more intense.

Who doesn't know Han Xin's role in the Chu-Han War?

Chen Tong's point of view is simply provoking everyone's cognition.

Even Professor Zhang and the others are all stunned at the moment.

Only the tomboy Zhang Zhao is full of curiosity. She is not a stickler, but likes to hear some novel viewpoints, so that the historical circle, which is like a pool of stagnant water, can stir up different waves.

………………

In the chat group, it exploded at this moment.

At this moment, Chongzhen could not believe it. Everyone said how important Han Xin was, but Chen Tong said that Han Xin was not important.

This directly shattered his inherent values.

Self-hanging southeast branch:

"I really don't understand this."

"Did Han Xin really not have a decisive role in the Chu-Han War?"

"Is the history I heard before all false?"

………………

Liu Bang snorted, his eyes full of pride.

Not everyone who kills the white snake is Xu Xian (Sage Monarch of Deception):

"I am very sure of that!"

"The only ones who really played a decisive role in the Chu-Han War are Liu Bang, Zhang Liang and Xiao He."

"These three have already secured the victory."

"The role of the other generals is only to shorten the time of the entire Chu-Han War, and they cannot influence the outcome at all."

"Look at the problem, look at the overall situation, look at the main contradiction, do you understand?"

………………

Wang Mang sneered, he felt that Liu Bang was putting too much money on his face.

First traverser:

"Don't talk so full!"

"Everyone's eyes are not blind."

"Everyone knows how important Han Xin is to Liu Bang."

"Why do you lie to yourself?"

"I just want to know: How can Chen Tong have the face to deny Han Xin's contribution?"

………………

At this moment, Chen Tong, in the eyes of everyone, calmly asked Shi Yi:

"You said that Han Xin helped Liu Bang a lot. Han Xin gave Liu Bang his army, which allowed Liu Bang to recover from the ashes."

"Then I just want to ask, why did Han Xin hand over the army to Liu Bang?"

"Is Han Xin the kind of person who is happy to help others?"

"Han Xin, he is the one who knows how to take advantage of the fire and raise prices from the ground."

"After he conquered Qi State, he encountered a life-and-death confrontation between Liu Bang and Xiang Yu. Han Xin wanted Liu Bang to make him king of Qi, so he was willing to send troops!"

"And during the Battle of Xingyang, Han Xin could obviously raise the price on the ground, so why did he willingly hand over the soldiers he had worked so hard to gather to Liu Bang?"

"Have you thought about it?"

Chen Tong's question made the scene dead silent.

"This"

Everyone was dumbfounded by Chen Tong's question.

Even the professors frowned and pondered, because this is the real eternal problem!

Professor Zhang shook his head and sighed:

"This is very puzzling. If you say that Han Xin's character is good, but then Han Xin sits on the ground and raises the price, it means that Han Xin's character is not very good."

"But what is the reason that makes Han Xin willing to hand over the military power?"

"This has always been a problem that has plagued the historians. No one can come up with convincing reasons."

The parents nodded again and again. There are many different opinions on the discussion of this issue.

But it can't completely convince the other party.

They all turned their attention to Shi Yi, wanting to see how this Shi Yi would answer?

And Shi Yi snorted:

"Chen Tong, you are a thief shouting "Stop a thief!"

"You first ruled out the theory of character. Isn't this deliberately inducing people's values?"

"It seems that character is untenable."

"In fact, people can explain it when they talk about character."

The parents at the moment all had a sneer on their faces, they felt that Shi Yi was not telling the truth.

The reason why Shi Yi insisted on sticking to his character was to put money on Han Xin's face, to prove that he was a good person.

Some parents directly exposed it at the time, mocking:

"Are you studying history?"

"Even laymen like us know that this may be the separation of the right to command and dispatch troops. Han Xin can lead these soldiers to fight, but he cannot command the ownership of these corps."

"This is why Liu Bang can easily obtain military power, because these corps belonged to Liu Bang."

"This is the same as the separation of use rights and ownership. Han Xin has the use rights, but Liu Bang has ownership. One is the tenant and the other is the owner."

"The owner, Liu Bang, has come to collect the house. Should the tenant, Han Xin, get out?"

The parents all looked contemptuous. They didn't question Shi Yi's knowledge and ability, because those who could be admitted to Qingbei University were definitely talented. What they questioned was Shi Yi's character.

Shi Yi just picks out some words that are in his interests and narrates, which is to force an explanation.

This is what really guides people's values.

…………

In the chat group, Cao Cao pouted.

Friends of wives:

"Wang Mang, look! What can you do at your level?"

"Any ordinary people in future generations can hang and beat you."

"The problem that can be found at a glance, what kind of character are you talking about?"

"An emperor believes in character, are you really stupid, or do you want to treat others as fools?"

…………

Wang Mang clenched his fists and did not respond, because what the parents said was indeed an opinion.

As for how to refute this point of view, Wang Mang felt that Shi Yi should be able to solve it.

Why should he do this?

If he wants to pretend to be a saint here, a saint should be tolerant, why bother with some villains?

This is so demeaning.

………………

In the auditorium, an imperceptible sneer flashed in Shi Yi's eyes. Are these parents worthy of talking about majors with him?

I can beat you in minutes.

Shi Yi looked at the parent who questioned him, and said firmly:

"What you said is just a possibility, but in times of war, the battle situation changes rapidly!"

"As for a commander like Han Xin, as long as you give him the command of the army, if he can't firmly control these soldiers, then there is something wrong with his ability!"

"Let the army you command be devoted to yourself, only know that there are generals, but not that there is an emperor, this is the basic ability of a famous general."