Subverted This is the Emperor Chat Group

………………

Chen Tong was about to talk about this topic, so of course he would not be polite.

Chen Tong:

"In the past, the Green Forest Army and the Red Eyebrow Army were indeed defined as peasant uprisings, because the previous research on history was very rough.

But as the study of history becomes more and more detailed, this classification is obviously untenable.

Take the Green Forest Army as an example, its top leaders are basically powerful landlords, even big families.

What does this have to do with farmers?

And let's talk about the Red Eyebrow Army again, why should I object to classifying the Red Eyebrow Army as a peasant uprising?

Let me start with point 1, which is the most important point.

The Red Eyebrow Army supported an emperor named Liu Penzi.

This is the main reason why the Red Eyebrow Army is not a peasant uprising! "

…………

That's it?That's it!

Liu Xiu was dumbfounded, he thought Chen Tong was going to say something shocking.

The result was that the Red Eyebrow Army supported an emperor.

Does this show that the Red Eyebrow Army is not a peasant uprising?

Liu Xiu felt that her three views had been destroyed.

Grand Magister:

"Are you joking?"

"Just because the red-browed army supports an emperor, does it prove that the red-browed army is not a peasant uprising?"

"What kind of bastard logic is this?"

"I don't see cause and effect at all."

………………

Not to mention that Liu Xiu couldn't see it, even Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty, Cao Cao and others were at a loss at the moment.

Even though it is far away, it will be punished (eternal overlord):

"Chen Tong, you are so insane and endless."

"Anyway, I don't see what you want to express?"

"The emperor's name is Liu Penzi. Is it directly related to whether the Red Eyebrow Army is a peasant uprising?"

…………

For a while, many emperors in the chat group were stunned, including Emperor Wu of the Northern Zhou Dynasty Yu Wenyong, Li Shimin, and even Yang Guang,

They were all confused by Chen Tong's remarks.

Everyone is thinking, why did Chen Tong say that,

Everyone wants to know what is Chen Tong's thinking angle?

But there is really no way to start.

Only Chongzhen was excited.

Self-hanging southeast branch (the purest faint king):

"I knew that the questions that Chen Tong was thinking about were never touched by others."

"That's what I do!"

………………

Are you fucking out of your mind?

Song Huizong had a look of disdain, and almost wanted to point at Chongzhen's nose and curse, no wonder everyone called you little stupid!

You are so stupid and cute.

The most beautiful thin golden body:

"Stop embarrassing yourself, okay?"

"Chen Tong is clearly talking nonsense."

"Everyone doesn't know, but Chen Tong knows?"

"I don't believe that there is any necessary connection between whether the emperor is Liu Penzi and whether the Red Eyebrow Army is a peasant uprising?"

………………

At this moment, even Li Zhi was dumbfounded, he really wanted to see Chen Tong roll over.

So he put down his work and waited for a good show.

But at this moment, Chen Tong was more confident.

Chen Tong:

"This is an angle that many people have never thought about!

That's class!

Who is Liu Penzi?

Liu Penzi is a blood descendant of the royal family of the Western Han Dynasty, that is to say, Liu Penzi is a real old nobleman!

Supporting Liu Penzi as emperor means acknowledging the ruling order of the nobility.

Then take a look at what a peasant uprising is?

The peasant uprising is to represent the interests of the peasant class. Who will be killed by the community first? ,

That is the aristocratic class pressing on top of them!

Did the real peasant uprising in history join forces with the old nobles?

If the Red Eyebrow Army is really a peasant uprising, and they really represent the interests of the peasant class, then the last thing they should do is to join forces with the nobles,

So, don’t you think it’s a disease for a red-browed army representing the peasantry to support the old aristocrats?

So from the perspective of class contradictions, this is the collapse!

The Red Eyebrow Army, which claims to be a peasant uprising, does not represent the interests of the peasants. Instead of overthrowing the ruling class, he wants to safeguard the interests of the nobles.

What do you think he has to do with the peasant uprising?

If you look at a real peasant uprising, he must overthrow the ruling class that is hostile to him. This is what a peasant uprising should do.

Whether it was Li Zicheng, the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom, or the peasant uprisings in the Song Dynasty, what they resented most were actually the royal family and officials.

If they want to establish a regime, they must establish a regime that belongs to the peasant class.

How could they possibly establish a regime belonging to the aristocracy?

There was a movement in history called Anti-Qing Fuming.

Just by looking at the program of this movement, you can tell that this is not a peasant uprising.

why?

Because they did not seek benefits for the peasants, but only wanted to overthrow the Qing Dynasty and rebuild the order of the Ming Dynasty.

And who are the people who participated in the anti-Qing and restoring the Ming Dynasty?

That basically belonged to the nobles of the Ming Dynasty, as well as the literati and bureaucrats of the Ming Dynasty.

How many ordinary people participated in this matter?

This is the main reason why the Red Eyebrow Army is not a peasant uprising!

Because the Red Eyebrow Army has been safeguarding the interests of the old nobles from the beginning to the end.

Then you say, what is the nature of the Red Eyebrow Army?

In fact, he is an armed force of the aristocracy. "

………………

As soon as Chen Tong finished talking, all the emperors in the group were stunned.

You can still look at it like this!

At this moment, Emperor Wu of the Han had to give Chen Tong a thumbs up, which was simply too sharp.

Even though it is far away, it will be punished (eternal overlord):

“This is what it means to truly understand history.

To judge whether it is a peasant uprising, shouldn't it be based on whether they represent the interests of the peasant class?

The peasant uprising worked hard to bring down the country, but in turn, it wanted to protect the interests of the old nobles.

But they want to support the old nobles as emperors.

To rebuild the ruling order of the old aristocracy.

You call this a peasant uprising?

You don't even recognize the basic class antagonism!

If the old nobles are allowed to continue to maintain their ruling order, what is the point of the peasant uprising?

Why should farmers shed blood and die?

Can't you just lie flat?

Anyway, whoever revolts or does not revolt represents the interests of the old nobles, why should they go to this muddy water?

Isn't this stupid? "

...............

Yue Fei's head was also buzzing, and now he admired Chen Tong so much.