Subverted This is the Emperor Chat Group

Or do you believe in the research of modern historians? "

1033. Was Liu Xiu's Du Tian Order Successful? (4700 words for subscription)

In the chat group, the emperors laughed.

Do you believe in those ancient historians, or do you believe in modern scholars of Chen Tong's era?

That doesn't require thinking about it at all, even Xiao Zhumeng knows who is more credible at this moment.

Self-hanging southeast branch (the purest faint king):

"Those historians in ancient times, their buttocks were crooked, and they were on the side of the nobles,"

"Because they are nobles themselves."

"And what about modern historians?"

"There is a high probability that they will still stand on the side of the common people."

"Because historical knowledge cannot be monopolized by them, if they even dare to falsify basic historical materials, their reputation will be bad."

"So there is basically no controversy about this kind of consensus among historians, and it must be more reliable than ancient historians."

"Of course we'll take what modern scholars say."

………………

Li Shimin felt extremely comfortable, as long as it was confirmed that Liu Xiu did not give the people an acre of land, then Liu Xiu would be a tyrant!

This is the same as Song Taizu Zhao Kuangyin, who is an institutional tyrant.

No matter how shameless or cruel other emperors are, they still have to allocate land to the people so that the people have a basis for living and hope for the future.

But a tyrant like this system completely kills all possibilities for the people.

Qiangu Li Er (the ruler of the Ming Dynasty and the sinner):

"Keep blowing?"

"No wonder you always talk about Liu Xiu's [Tian Du Tian Ling] in a vague way. It turns out that Liu Xiu is hiding such a big shady scene."

"This is the same as Zhao Kuangyin's history."

"Never talk about how serious Zhao Kuangyin's land annexation is,"

"But he always brags that Zhao Kuangyin treats the people like a son and diverts people's attention."

"What's the use of just blowing with your mouth?"

"Even if the land is not allocated, how can the common people have a good life?"

"So Liu Xiu is definitely the worst in history in terms of loving the people like a child,"

"That's on the same level as Song Taizu Zhao Kuangyin and donkey cart drifting Zhao Guangyi,"

"That's exploiting the common people."

………………

Liu Xiu felt cold all over her body, you must be too ruthless.

Are you going to call me a tyrant because of this one incident?

But at this moment, he has no way to refute, because he knows better than anyone whether the [Field Duty Order] has been successfully implemented.

He had no point of rebuttal at all.

..........

At this moment, Song Huizong was so angry that his face turned red, and he absolutely did not allow others to slander the Confucian emperor.

Confucian emperors are full of benevolence, righteousness and morality. Could it be that they are not as good as the executioners of Legalist emperors?

The legalist emperor is famous for his love of killing, is he blind?

The most beautiful thin golden body:

"Don't be led by Chen Tong."

"Didn't he say before: don't listen to what others say about the emperor, you must look at the emperor's specific system?"

"Why do you now hear that modern scholars believe that Liu Xiu's [Tian Du Ling] failed?"

"You don't even read the history books, but you agree that Chen Tong's point of view is correct?"

"What if all modern scholars are wrong?"

………………

Empress Lu patted her forehead, do you think this kind of thing is possible?

Can modern scholars be wrong?

This kind of treatment is infinitely close to zero.

You must know that modern scholars often fight with each other, and rarely reach a consensus on a point of view.

As long as there is a consensus, it is basically the truth.

But Empress Lu also knows that if you don't beat him to death like Song Huizong, he will never admit defeat.

And Empress Lu also wanted to know, why do modern scholars believe that the "Dutian Order" failed?

First Empress Dowager (Yanhuang First Empress):

"Chen Tong, you must teach them how to behave."

"Don't let these brainless fans of Liu Xiu brag about [Tian Du Tian Ling] all day long."

"A failed system, a system that is not enforced, what is there to brag about?"

………………

Chen Tong nodded, of course this must be made clear.

Chen Tong:

"Actually, the [Field Duty Order] was not successfully implemented, and you can draw this conclusion from many aspects.

The first aspect is imperial power and ministerial power.

Liu Xiu started his career by being an aristocrat, he himself did not belong to the real direct line,

Moreover, the power of the Western Han royal family was also greatly weakened at that time.

It was even during the founding war that the Western Han royal family fought severely and completely wiped out their own strength.

Such a Liu Xiu, who was able to ascend to the throne relying on a powerful family, what strength does he have to resist the powerful family?

What can you do if people don't carry out your [Field Duty Order]? "

………………

Yu Wenyong, Emperor Wu of the Northern Zhou Dynasty who had been silent in the group, also spoke.

He really couldn't stand these people bragging about Liu Xiu without thinking.

The most ruthless wolf dad:

"In my heart, only absolute power is the only truth.

Just like those emperors who want to destroy Buddhism, you can only implement this system if you overwhelm the Buddha.

Don’t say it’s as big as your family and country, but as small as your family. If your son’s achievements are higher than yours, do you still want your son to listen to you?

Do you think it's realistic?

Not to mention a wife-fearing softie like Emperor Wen of Sui, because his wife is better than him,

He dare not mess with his wife Dugu Jialuo,

So after the two couples quarreled, it turned out to be the majestic emperor of a country who ran away from home.

Isn't this embarrassing?

Doesn't this still have a little bit of man's dignity?

If it was me, I would be killed by a head bump.

This is true for both father and son couples. They have no blood relationship with you, and there is no aristocratic family with no inheritance relationship.

Who would put you in the eyes of an emperor without imperial power? "

………………

Emperor Wen of the Sui Dynasty had a dark face, and he knew that as long as his deadly enemy joined the group, he would definitely hate himself for nothing.

But there is nothing wrong with this truth.

As small as a family, as large as a country, there is always an unbreakable truth, that is, strength determines the right to speak.

Wife-loving Maniac (One Emperor through the ages):

"Now how are you going to brag about Liu Xiu?"

"Don't you tell me that those aristocratic families all have the great sentiment of burning themselves and illuminating others?"

………………

Empress Lu, Wu Zetian's eyes were full of sarcasm, if the reform could go so smoothly.

Will reform still involve bloodshed?

Will reform be so difficult?

If the vested interests are willing to give up their interests, will there still be class conflicts?

Liu Xiu was left speechless by the question, and all fools know that only benefits are the unbreakable truth.

The nobles lie on the people to suck blood and eat meat, how could they give up their own interests to feed back the people!

Then how do they exploit people?

How can you enjoy the glory and wealth?