Subverted This is the Emperor Chat Group

"Because this belongs to the category of history, then I am an expert in history, and what I say is the truth!"

"A very simple example, the battle between Xiang Yu and Liu Bang, historians believe that Liu Bang's war ability is not as good as Xiang Yu's, the first in history!"

"Do you think it's believable?"

"For example, as long as you don't open granaries to release grain, then you are a fool. Any official who prevents you from opening granaries will bring disaster to the country and the people."

"They never cared whether it was right or wrong to open warehouses to release grain."

"why?"

"Because historians don't understand economics, because historians don't understand sociology, and because historians don't understand military affairs!"

"Then here comes the question, don't you feel uncomfortable?"

"Are these questions just historical?"

"what do y'all think?"

"These people who talk about things with traditional historiography, they always say that others are laymen, and they are experts."

"But think about it for yourself. A history student only understands historical knowledge, and he evaluates the emperor's strategy."

"What is the emperor? It's about political economy, the boss and decision-maker in all aspects."

"In terms of politics and economy, the emperor is a professional!"

"Are you better at being an emperor than other emperors?"

"If you are a historian in this regard, then you are definitely a stubborn bronze. The emperor is the king and a professional player."

"He just eats this bowl of rice. If this bowl of rice explodes, he will lose his life, his wife will be robbed, and his family will be wiped out!"

"People's wealth and life are all on it, don't they understand better than you?"

"Let me tell you, he is a foolish emperor, he even knows how to be an emperor better than historians!"

"Who is using the level of stubborn bronze to evaluate the strongest king?"

"Who is really evaluating professionals in a non-professional capacity?"

"It's these people who hold the traditional view of history."

"The interpretation of history in their mouths can never be separated from benevolence, righteousness and morality, and can never be separated from benevolent tyrants, and they are never pragmatic."

"Because they don't have the ability to analyze everything, which involves countless connections!"

"In addition to archaeology, in addition to sorting out the offerings, in addition to judging the data recorded on the words."

"These people who only study history, do they understand economics? Does they understand politics? Does they understand military affairs? Does they understand social psychology?"

"I don't understand anything!"

"You dare to judge others?"

"Just like Emperor Wanli who doesn't go to court, people can hang and beat your historian 1 times, believe it or not!"

"You still say that he is a fool!"

"In ancient times, people played you to death, and you didn't know how you died."

After Chen Tong finished speaking, there was a moment of silence in the live broadcast room, and then some people came to their senses.

"That's right, talking about professional and non-professional is a lie!"

"They are professionals in history, but their major is to read ancient documents, learn to date and restore objects, and organize the most primitive data and information retrieval in history."

"To evaluate a historical figure, you are an amateur!"

"Do you understand economics? Do you understand politics? Do you understand military? Do you understand social psychology?"

"I don't understand anything!"

"If this is divided into each field in detail, who is the layman, isn't this a clear thing?"

"Anchor, it's obvious that you have a problem!"

"Not only did you lie to us that there is only one view of history, but you don't even tell us this view of history. Those of you who study history are laymen!"

"You still have the face to say that others laugh at the king with bronze, but you are the king of bronze laugh!"

The entire live broadcast room immediately exploded.

People who study history have brains, but without brains, who likes to read history?

Such an intricate relationship between characters, they debated and debated.

That's mind-boggling!

The face of the master history master turned green at that time.

I couldn't say a word for a long time, because what Chen Tong said was the truth!

806. Traditional Historiography vs. Cutting-edge Historiography (4000 words for subscription)

At this moment, in the chat group, the emperors laughed loudly.

Friends of wives:

"What is it called talking on paper?"

"That's the so-called history experts. If you only understand history, then why do you criticize my system and policies?"

"You still comment on my true ability?"

"Do you know anything about military affairs?"

"The military you think is that whoever has the most is the most powerful. The military you think is that if I beat you away, and if I win you, then I will win?"

"You don't even understand a single sentence in the name of Sun Tzu's Art of War,"

"Go to battle and plan, the soldiers are deceitful!"

........................

At this moment, Li Yuan is also full of ridicule.

The mediocre Patriarch Li (Heroic Lord in Troubled Times):

"If you don't go to court, you are a fool?"

"Is Ming Jun the one who goes to court to review memorials all day long?"

"Is this the lack of ability and hard work to make up for it?"

"Don't you know what it means: to win a thousand miles away by strategizing?"

"Don't emperors have to go to war every time they go to war?"

"Know what it means to be a good fighter without great achievements?"

"Even the genius doctor Bian Que knows that a top doctor can prevent your disease, and treatment is only the last resort!"

"Isn't this just like Sima Guang? He doesn't know how to operate things, and his ability to govern is basically zero, but he still evaluates who is incapable of governing!"

"I'm surprised, isn't this just a typical paper talk?"

"Why do so many people believe it?"

"You have to look at other people's evaluations. You first have to look at the person you are evaluating, whether he has the height and ability!"

At this moment, Chen Tong saw that the crowd in the live broadcast room was already excited, and many people began to doubt the master of history, so he continued to add more information.

Chen Tong said with a smile:

"I think everyone has doubts by now."

"It's actually very simple. Look at those short videos who often like to cross-professional to comment on others and social phenomena."

"Will they be ridiculed frequently?"

"I have seen many art majors, acting students, broadcasting hosts, and even dubbing students evaluate economic issues. Don't you think they are evaluating the king with bronze?"

"An economic question, even those economists may get it wrong, let alone a layman?"

"These are all things that happened around you. You can't judge right from wrong, let alone a non-professional person to evaluate things that happened in ancient times."

"And this phenomenon has long been noticed by historians, so there has been a trend of thought in the history circle, called the new school!"

"What they are advocating is a cutting-edge view of history."

"What is the cutting-edge view of history?"

"That's using multidisciplinary thinking, what I call multidimensional analysis!"

"The profession of a historian is archeology to date, to explain when and what era this object appeared, and you to search for historical materials."

"You judge the authenticity of the historical materials, and you organize all the historical materials into a collection. This is your job."

"As for how to evaluate the emperor, that's very embarrassing, you historians don't count."

"An emperor's evaluation, if it involves economic issues."

"That's what an economist should do. From an economic point of view, whether his economic policies are problematic and effective!"

"Did you do something bad with good intentions?"

"It doesn't mean that your starting point is good, and you are right."

"After you opened the granary and released the grain, there was a big disturbance, a plague, and a rebellion. Are you correct?"

"That only shows that your ability to govern is not good enough!"

"As for military strategy, can you historians understand?"

"Do you know what it means to subordinate tactics to strategy? Do you know what it means to subordinate short-term interests to long-term interests?"

"Do you know what it means to go to war?"

"Do you know what the core technology of ancient military is?"

"Do you know what is the state of mind of a man in war?"

"You know that when the generals in ancient times fought, their command was seen from every book of war. What kind of military principles did they follow?"