Lawyer's character

Seeing that there was no one around, Wang Deyou whispered: "The client's surname is Gao, her name is Gao Ying, she is a woman, she lives in the suburbs, and she has a younger brother.

Lawyer Qian Wen was the one who went to the previous court session. It was said that Gao Ying had found a partner a long time ago, but her family said that the man was older and had a son in elementary school, and they did not agree to her marrying him. Gao Yingxun insisted on getting married, and the two sides almost broke off the relationship between father and daughter.

When the man saw that the Gao family disagreed and made a big fuss, he stopped contacting Gao Ying and changed his mobile phone number. Since then, Gao Ying has become ill and always feels that her family is trying to harm her.

In fact, you can't tell she has a problem at ordinary times, but don't irritate her, or she will get sick when stimulated. Last year, Gao Ying's family was demolished in the suburbs. The family happily signed the demolition agreement. Her family got a three-bedroom apartment and a one-bedroom apartment, as well as hundreds of thousands in compensation.

Her parents wanted to give the three-bedroom apartment to her brother. Her brother was not married yet, so he had a house so that he could get a wife. The hundreds of thousands of yuan in compensation were reserved for her brother to get a wife. One bedroom belongs to her.

The old man favors sons over daughters, and this division is also in line with local customs. After all, if the daughter gets married, the water will be thrown out. In the future, the daughter will belong to another family, so it is good to give her a one-bedroom apartment.

There are many families in Gao Ying's village. The money and houses for demolition were only given to the sons, not the daughters. In the end, the family went to court to file a lawsuit. There were too many such things.

After Gao Ying's parents told their children about the distribution of property, Gao Ying felt it was unreasonable and had a quarrel with his family. Most people will be angry for a few days at most, and they will get better after a while. At worst, there will be a gap between family members, and they will move around less in the future.

But Gao Ying was different. Her brain had been stimulated before because of her affair. This time, her family members stimulated her again. She felt that everyone in the family was attracted to her brother, and she had been in poor health in the past few years. She felt that it was all The family was so troublesome that the whole family wished she would die early, and then they had the idea of ​​​​revenge on her family. "Wang Deyou said this and took a sip of beer.

At this moment, the waiter brought the dishes and the two chatted while eating.

"What happened next? How did she take revenge?" Fang Yi asked.

"This woman is really cruel. I don't know where she got a small bottle of sulfuric acid. After returning home, she took advantage of the family's unpreparedness and poured sulfuric acid on her parents and younger brother.

Later, forensic identification by the public security organ showed that her parents and younger brother were both seriously injured. Among them, his parents' disability level is level three, and her brother's disability level is level nine. The public security organs determined that she had committed intentional injury and arrested her.

Later, the public security bureau heard from her parents that she was mentally abnormal, so the Public Security Bureau entrusted the Municipal Psychiatric Illness Appraisal Committee and the Provincial Psychiatric Illness Appraisal Committee to conduct two judicial appraisals of mental illness on her. Both concluded that she suffered from schizophrenia. Lack of responsibility when committing the crime.

Later, the police released her. "Wang Deyou said.

"You should not bear legal responsibility if you have no capacity for responsibility. Why was you sentenced to death later?" Fang Yi asked in confusion.

"Her parents could forgive her, but her brother refused. Later, her brother raised objections to the public security organs and asked the public security organs and prosecutors to re-evaluate her sister Gao Ying's mental illness.

The Public Security Bureau also commissioned the Forensic Authentication Science and Technology Institute of the Ministry of Justice to conduct a forensic appraisal of Gao Ying's mental illness. The appraisal concluded that Gao Ying was not mentally ill and committed the crime due to emotional reactions. Gao Ying has full responsibility. Just like that, the public security organs arrested Gao Ying again. "Wang Deyou said.

"The appraisal results before and after are different. How did the court decide?" Fang Yi asked.

"At that time, lawyer Qian Wen went to the trial. It was said that lawyer Song checked her, so it was just a formality. She defended Gao Ying's innocence based on the conclusion of the previous appraisal, but the court did not accept it.

The collegial bench believed that, in addition to relying on the materials submitted for inspection, the appraisal staff of the Forensic Authentication Science Institute of the Ministry of Justice also went to the place where the crime occurred to conduct on-site investigation and understanding. On this basis, the appraisal conclusion made was relatively objective and fair, so it accepted the following conclusion. identification conclusion.

The Intermediate People's Court held that the defendant Gao Ying deliberately hurt others' bodies by throwing sulfuric acid, causing serious injuries to three people. His behavior constituted the crime of intentional injury. Gao Ying's injury to his immediate family members was not caused by the intensification of family disputes. It was entirely caused by his personal intolerance. The method was particularly cruel and the consequences were particularly serious. He should be severely punished in accordance with the law.

In the end, the Intermediate People's Court convicted Gao Ying of intentional injury, sentenced him to death, and deprived him of his political rights for life. After the first-instance verdict was announced, Gao Ying did not appeal, and the public prosecution did not protest. The Intermediate People's Court reports the case level by level in accordance with the law and reviews the death penalty.

Then a dramatic scene happened. "Wang Deyou finished speaking. He picked up a piece of pot-wrapped meat and ate it.

"Old Wang, don't act like a storyteller, hurry up and say the next thing." Fang Yi picked up the beer and poured him a glass, urging.

"Didn't I say I'm hungry? Let's eat a piece of meat first.

During the review of the death penalty, because the conclusions of the first three mental illness appraisals were conflicting, the Provincial High Court considered it necessary to conduct a re-examination, so it organized medical experts to conduct a fourth mental illness appraisal on the defendant Gao Ying. The appraisal conclusion was: The defendant Gao Ying Ying suffers from schizophrenia and has no capacity for criminal responsibility.

After the High Court received the appraisal conclusion, Gao Ying was released again. "Wang Deyou said.

"What happened next?" Fang Yi picked up the wine glass and asked.

"Because the opinions of the previous four appraisal conclusions were too different, the Provincial High Court, out of caution, decided to entrust the Judicial Identification Center of the Supreme People's Court to organize psychiatric experts to conduct a fifth review and appraisal of Gao Ying. The fifth appraisal conclusion is: : Gao Ying has the ability to limit criminal liability when committing a crime.

The Provincial High Court reviewed and held that the defendant Gao Ying committed the crime of intentional injury, and the method was particularly cruel, causing serious injuries to three people, two of whom were seriously disabled. The consequences were particularly serious and should be severely punished according to law.

Since Gao Ying could not fully identify and control his behavior when committing the crime, he can be given a lighter punishment. The sentence was changed to: death penalty, execution suspended for two years, and deprivation of political rights for life. At this point, the case was considered over, and Gao Ying was imprisoned again.

I went to the High Court this afternoon to get the criminal verdict. "Wang Deyou said.

"This case is not complicated. The key is that psychiatric identification is more complicated. Especially when a psychiatric identification is conducted a long time after the case, it is obviously difficult. But it is about human life, and it must be done." Fang Yidao.

"Well, that's true. It took more than two years from the incident to the last psychiatric evaluation. During the last evaluation, the forensic psychiatry experts not only read the files, but also consulted Gao Ying's family members, colleagues, correctional officers, and criminals detained in the same room. The suspect, the first-instance judge of this case, the prosecutor of this case and other relevant personnel conducted a comprehensive investigation, basically questioning everyone around Gao Ying.

We also conducted investigations and interviews with the experts who participated in the previous appraisals of this case. It can be seen that the experts did a lot of work in the last appraisal. We cannot say whether it is accurate or not, but the conclusion is relatively objective. "Wang Deyou said.

"Well, this kind of case is really rare." Fang Yi picked up the wine glass and said.