step by step addiction

In court, the plaintiff and the defendant each have their own side.

After the judge announced the opening of the trial, Du Ting still launched a fierce attack on Chen Liang immediately.

"May I ask the defendant, do you admit to pushing the plaintiff downstairs?"

Chen Liang wanted to explain, "It's because..."

"You just need to answer 'yes' or 'no'." Du Ting interrupted indifferently.

Chen Liang was very aggrieved, but based on the facts, he could only answer depressedly: "Yes."

Du Ting immediately asked again, "May I ask the defendant, what kind of psychology did you push the plaintiff downstairs?"

Chen Liang's face calmed down a little. Ji Yunsu had already had a similar drill with him on this issue.

According to what Ji Yunsu taught, he said concisely, "That was an accident."

"Our client refused to provide a medical diagnosis certificate, so you held a grudge, so you came to block our client?" Du Ting asked again.

"Objection." Ji Yunsu stood up calmly, "The plaintiff's lawyer guessed subjectively, and there is no evidence to prove the reason for our client's behavior."

The judge looked at Du Ting, "The objection is valid. The plaintiff's lawyer please provide sufficient evidence."

Du Ting smiled proudly at Ji Yunsu, and then produced a piece of evidence, which was the snapshot of Chen Liang running a red light and the point deduction notice.

"This is the evidence. The defendant ran six red lights without authorization and his driver's license was revoked. The defendant asked the plaintiff for a certificate to no avail. He wanted revenge, so he went to the door and pushed the plaintiff down the stairs."

Ji Yunsu stood up again, "I object. This evidence has nothing to do with our client's actions."

This is just a motive. If there is a conflict, there will be a motive, but if there is a motive, it does not necessarily mean that the crime will be committed.

The judge nodded approvingly, "The objection is valid. The plaintiff, please provide more clear evidence."

Du Ting gritted her teeth and sat back.

Ji Yunsu stood up, faced Feng Yuanyuan, and asked the first question.

"May I ask the plaintiff, why did you refuse to provide the defendant with a medical diagnosis certificate?"

Feng Yuanyuan's words were still the same as she said before, she didn't want to encourage this phenomenon of running a red light.

Ji Yunsu asked again: "May I ask the plaintiff, why did you believe that your child's condition was not serious at that time? Have you ever had a similar experience before?"

Feng Yuanyuan's expression froze, she lowered her eyes and did not answer for a while.

Du Ting stood up and retorted, "No, this issue has nothing to do with this case."

The judge denied, "The objection is invalid, please answer the plaintiff truthfully."

Only then did Feng Yuanyuan reply: "Yes, similar situations have happened before, so I didn't panic too much."

Ji Yunsu immediately chased after him, "May I ask the plaintiff, why did you allow the defendant to continue running through the remaining five red lights when you knew that the child's condition was not serious and the defendant ran through one red light?"

Du Ting frowned, "I object. The defendant's lawyer subjectively speculates about our client's behavior."

The judge nodded, "The objection is valid. Please pay attention to the wording of the defendant's lawyer."

Ji Yunsu put it another way, "May I ask the plaintiff, did you take the initiative to remind the defendant to obey the traffic rules after you knew that your child's condition was not serious and the defendant ran a red light?"

Feng Yuanyuan paused before saying, "I was so frightened that I didn't dare to say anything."

"So you didn't stop it." Ji Yunsu concluded for her, and then handed over a piece of audio and video evidence, which was provided by the online car-hailing platform.

As soon as the sound source was played, a female voice was heard crying anxiously, "Master, my child is sick, please take me to the hospital quickly."

Followed by video.Feng Yuanyuan got into the car with a twitching child in her arms, with panic and panic on her face, even though the video was not very clear, it was still clearly visible.

Ji Yunsu finally said: "Judge, since our client got his driver's license, except for the plaintiff's bill, he has never committed any traffic violations such as running a red light. It can be proved that this time running a red light six times is really eager to save people. Our party received the plaintiff's "anxious, sick" distress signal and offered to help.

Our party did not show any violent or extreme behavior during the whole process, and even comforted the plaintiff with words such as "I will be there soon" and "15 minutes", because the plaintiff's reason for "not daring to stop because of fright" is not sufficient.I have every reason to believe that our client ran six red lights in a row with the acquiescence of the plaintiff. "

"I object. The defendant's lawyer does not have sufficient evidence to prove it, and what he said just now is mostly subjective speculation." Du Ting said.

Ji Yunsu immediately retorted, "This view is based on the common sense of the public, and it can be established."

"The objection is invalid. The plaintiff's lawyer sits back in your seat," said the judge.

Du Ting was defeated one after another, and her heart was so suffocated that in the second round, she directly threw out her trump card, which was a video. In the video, Chen Liang was fighting with a man, and there were several people fighting around.

"Defendant, in this video, did you beat someone after having an altercation, please answer 'yes' or 'no'."

Chen Liang frowned, although he really wanted to explain why he did it, but he would not be allowed to say a word here.

He hummed aggrievedly, "Yes."

Du Ting turned to face the judge, "Judge, at the time of the incident, the defendant and the plaintiff had an argument due to disagreement, and then pushed the plaintiff downstairs. There is good reason to suspect that defendant intentionally injured plaintiff."

"I object. The evidence provided by the plaintiff's lawyer has nothing to do with this case, and does not have any reference or even proof significance." Ji Yunsu rejected it.

"The objection is valid."

Du Ting was not annoyed. There was an obvious loophole in this case, that is, neither the defendant nor the plaintiff had clear directional evidence.

For example, in the evidence video, there is evidence of the beating between the two parties, but Chen Liang and Feng Yuanyuan had no witnesses at the time of the incident, and there was no audio and video evidence. Even Chen Liang refused to admit that pushing Feng Yuanyuan downstairs was fine.

However, Chen Liang admitted, that's why she claimed the crime of intentional wounding, because Chen Liang himself admitted that he pushed Feng Yuanyuan, which was almost tantamount to surrendering himself.

In this case, there was no suspense. The defendant voluntarily confessed to the crime, and Feng Yuanyuan was also injured. It doesn't matter what happened in the middle. What everyone wants is the result.

Therefore, she is not disappointed that Du Ting's evidence was overturned. She knows that this is just a piece of irrelevant evidence, but for the case where there is no directional evidence, this video will undoubtedly leave a stereotype in the minds of the jury and the judge. impression.

The plaintiff does have a "conviction."

Sure enough, although the evidence was refuted, the jury exchanged glances with each other. Originally, this was a verdict without any suspense, but now it made them more clear about how to judge.

Chen Liang was flustered.He admits that sometimes he can't help being impulsive when he is provoked, but he really has no intention of harming others.

Thinking of his own family, Chen Liang, a middle-aged man, also wiped his tears, and he murmured softly, "I really didn't mean it, I really just pushed it lightly."

Looking at the last few pieces of evidence in his hand, Ji Yunsu stood still for a moment before getting up and coming to Feng Yuanyuan, "May I ask the plaintiff, your son was convulsed at the time, why was he diagnosed after going to the hospital?"

Feng Yuanyuan's eyes flashed, but she didn't answer right away.