Director: The special effects are too expensive, so I had to make real shots
Chapter 100 Judgment Day!The fierce battle between the two sides (Part 1)
Chapter 100 Judgment Day!The fierce battle between the two sides (first update)
The car escorting Liu Yong slowed down by a gear under the driver's operation, and slowly drove forward on the wide road in front of the trial court.
Both sides of the road.
Crowds of CML patients wearing masks stopped and looked at the escort vehicle.
The elderly, middle-aged men and women, teenagers, and children in the crowd, each of them looked so pure at the moment, and each of them was looking forward to Liu Yong's happy ending today.
When the escort vehicle slowly passed by.
Every chronic myelogenous leukemia patient present took off their masks, and they paid tribute to Liu Yong, the "God of Medicine", with their most sincere feelings.
The bailiff Xiao Li sitting in the escort car was also very sad, but also very moved.
The warmth of human nature warmed the hearts of many people at this moment. Marshal Xiao Li was very pleased that these CML patients who had been rescued by Liu Yong did not forget him and came to support Liu Yong on this very important day.
As the escort vehicle slowly drove to the gate of the Yuzhou Trial Court, the media reporters on the scene did not swarm up to film and report as usual, but at an appropriate distance, they reported to netizens and netizens who were concerned about Liu Yong's incident across the country. The audience introduced the situation at the scene.
And at this time at the gate of the trial court.
In addition to Xu Nuo and Liu Yong's attorney Yuan Xiang, there are also Professor Huang Wenqiang from the research and development team of the domestic new drug [Ponatinib], Xu Zheng, Tan Jia, Zhang Yu, Yang Jiuming from the crew of "I'm Not the God of Medicine", etc. The main actors and many crew members are here.
"Mr. Xu, I'll go there first."
Seeing that Liu Yong had been escorted over, Yuan Xiang told Xu Nuo.
"Uh-huh."
Xu Nuo nodded.
He knew that Yuan Xiang had to make some preparations at this time, and when the trial started later, he would act as Liu Yong's attorney to defend in court.
This time, the opponent is Liu Jiang, the attorney representing the European Nori Pharmaceutical Group.
Although the imatinib of European Nori Pharmaceutical Group has quietly withdrawn from the domestic market, in fact, it was forced to withdraw because no domestic patients bought their drug anymore.
But the European Nuori Pharmaceutical Group is still not reconciled.
The market is gone, and they can't swallow this breath, so they want to work on the Liu Yong incident. Simply put, they want to disgust people and send Liu Yong to jail.
Therefore, European Nori Pharmaceutical Group sued Liu Yong to the court for selling counterfeit drugs and other charges.
Nowadays.
It is an open trial of the Liu Yong case open to the public, and the entire trial will be broadcast live to the public.
Since this case is very special and highly concerned, it has a certain educational and learning significance, and it may play a role in promoting the construction of the rule of law.
For this reason, the Political and Legal Affairs Bureau of Yuzhou also specially organized a live broadcast of the various departments under its jurisdiction. In addition, colleges and universities such as Yuzhou University of Political Science and Law also organized students to watch today's trial of Liu Yong's case.
"Everyone should read carefully and analyze carefully. Who is Liu Yong's attorney? I don't think I need to say more, right?"
Teacher Wang from the law school paced back and forth on the podium of the lecture theater, speaking slowly to the students present.
"It's Senior Brother Yuan!"
"Brother Yuan is awesome!"
"Mr. Wang, will the Liu Yong case be included in our legal textbooks?"
"Mr. Wang, I don't think Liu Yong's case can be judged with just cold laws."
"But judging from the current situation, Liu Yong has indeed committed a crime."
The students below immediately started talking.
"Whether it can be included in the textbook depends on how the sentence will be judged today. Two days ago, your Senior Brother Yuan had a phone call with me. He said that he would defend Liu Yong from multiple perspectives. What about Xiao Yuan? Brothers of yours, you all have to learn how others act as defense lawyers in court, understand?"
Teacher Wang shook his head, and at the same time used Yuan Xiang, a barrister who went abroad from Yuzhou University of Political Science and Law, to educate these law students who are still in school.
"Know it!"
All the students answered in unison.
In fact, regarding the Liu Yong incident, since Liu Yong was arrested, the law students in the school have not stopped discussing this case, because on the one hand, Liu Yong has indeed committed a crime in terms of legal provisions, but On the other hand, Liu Yong's actions have indeed greatly helped patients with chronic myeloid leukemia, and it can be said that they have saved the lives of many patients with chronic myelogenous leukemia.
A method of illegal behavior was used to save lives, and many law students discussed it. Is this a kind of emergency avoidance?
Because those chronic myelogenous leukemia patients who were saved by Liu Yong couldn't afford the sky-high price of medicines from the European Nori Pharmaceutical Group, and the only thing that could save their lives was the generic medicine of Asan at that time.
Moreover, Liu Yong himself is also a patient with chronic myeloid leukemia. He has eaten up his million-dollar fortune in the past few years, and he has to take generic medicines of Asan in order to survive.
Law students have continued to discuss the Liu Yong incident until today.
When they saw that more and more people paid attention to Liu Yong and his incident, these law students felt extremely gratified in their hearts. Generally, for cases with high attention like this, the penalty is usually All will be cautious.
Now the pressure came to the Yuzhou Trial Court.
In fact, the main focus of the crime committed by Liu Yong is whether he constituted the sale of counterfeit drugs, because the prosecuting party in this case is the European Nori Pharmaceutical Group. After all, the sale of counterfeit drugs has seriously affected the sales of genuine drugs of their pharmaceutical company.
As for illegal purchasing and smuggling, Liu Yong was prosecuted by the prosecutors, but as long as he was found not guilty of selling counterfeit drugs, then taking into account various factors, the prosecution of illegal purchasing and smuggling would be able to comply. Due to the reasonable wishes of the broad masses of the people, no lawsuit was filed against Liu Yong.
Today Yuan Xiang is going to focus on defending Liu Yong in selling counterfeit medicines.
As for illegal purchasing and smuggling, this is secondary.
After Liu Yong was escorted to the trial court, the on-site jurors entered one after another, and more people were waiting outside the court for the result of the trial.
Of course, people can also take out their mobile phones and directly watch the live video broadcast of the trial court to understand the progress in real time.
Today's trial of Liu Yong's case undoubtedly occupied the headlines of the major news pages, and attracted countless netizens to pay close attention to the trend of the trial.
As for the plaintiff Fang Europe Nuo Rui Pharmaceutical Group, whose reputation has already rotted into the ditch, it has already been scolded crazy by netizens at this moment.
"Garbage Europe Nori Pharmaceutical Group, bah!"
"Support Liu Yong!"
"The European Nori Pharmaceutical Group's medicines can't be sold anymore, and now they are still biting about Liu Yong. It's really disgusting."
"@Europe Nuorui Pharmaceutical Group, no one is buying your medicine."
"I'm really glad that Director Xu's company in our country has developed a new drug, otherwise I don't know how arrogant the European Nori Pharmaceutical Group is at the moment!"
"If I were the European Nori Pharmaceutical Group, I would withdraw the lawsuit at this time, and then Liu Yong's illegal purchasing agent and smuggling prosecutors would also withdraw the lawsuit. Wouldn't they be acquitted?"
"@Europe Nuorui Pharmaceutical Group, come out and bark! Where are people?"
"To be honest, if there is no new domestic drug developed by Xu Dao Company, the European Nuo Rui Pharmaceutical Group must be very arrogant at the moment, and domestic patients with chronic myelogenous leukemia still cannot do without their drugs, so it is estimated that Liu Yong will be given a light sentence this time. The probability is much lower.”
"If Liu Yong is sentenced lightly or is not guilty today, Dao Xu's new drug must have contributed!"
"I'm so pissed off at the European Nuori Pharmaceutical Group. If it weren't for this broken company, Liu Yong would have been released a long time ago."
"@Europe Nuorui Pharmaceutical Group, why don't you die, you!"
Netizens have hated this European Nori Pharmaceutical Group for a long time, and now they can't wait to pull it out and spit one by one.
But as many people said, if Xu Nuo's company hadn't developed new drugs, it is estimated that the European Nuo Rui Pharmaceutical Group would be more arrogant at this moment, and then punish Liu Yong to death. After all, Liu Yong was arrested at the time At that time, the director Xu Nuo stood up to speak for Liu Yong, but the result was an arrogant reply from the European Nori Pharmaceutical Group.
Only now.
When there are already very low-priced domestically produced new drugs in the country, the European Nuori Pharmaceutical Group has already dared not release another one.
Because there is no room for them to survive in the field of chronic myelogenous leukemia drugs, at this moment the European Norry Pharmaceutical Group can only look forward to being able to sue Liu Yong and give Liu Yong a sentence.
Netizens thought at the beginning that the European Nuori Pharmaceutical Group did not dare to come out arrogantly and force Lai Lai.
Only found out later.
Good guy, it turns out that the major social media platforms have already banned the European Nori Pharmaceutical Group, and severely authorized a wave.
The scene of the trial.
Xu Nuo, his assistant Wen Ruohan, Professor Huang Wenqiang, the R&D team of the new domestic drug ponatinib, and the main actors of "I'm Not the God of Medicine" sat in the front of the auditorium.
A small number of patients with chronic myelogenous leukemia also came to the auditorium.
After all, the group of patients with chronic myelogenous leukemia is too large, and it is impossible for everyone to come to the auditorium to listen, so a small number of people were selected to come.
In addition, many well-known and upright people from the media, legal circles, and medical circles also came to the auditorium. After all, this is a case that almost everyone pays attention to.
After a while, the trial officially began.
The plaintiff and the defendant had a heated debate on whether Liu Yong sold counterfeit medicines. Yuan Xiang is worthy of being a well-known barrister in China. Facing the pressure of the European Norry Pharmaceutical Group, he was not at all panicked. Take it easy every step of the way.
Whenever the plaintiff accused Liu Yong of selling counterfeit drugs from a tricky point of view, Yuan Xiang could defend with ease.
However, the European Nuori Pharmaceutical Group is killing them all. Liu Yong’s sale of counterfeit drugs has seriously affected the sales of their genuine drugs during that period, and before and after the emergence of Asan generic drugs, the European Nuori Pharmaceutical Group’s drug imatinib Ni's sales curve and data are listed.
Yuan Xiang defended the drug on the grounds of the unreasonable pricing of drugs by the European Nori Pharmaceutical Group itself and the double standards at home and abroad.
That's exactly what happened.
The price of the drug imatinib was originally priced by the European Nori Pharmaceutical Group, which was seriously unreasonable when compared with domestic and foreign regions.
Because they sell a box of medicine for 24000 yuan in China, and even raised the price to 27000 yuan after Liu Yong was arrested.
The price of this drug abroad is about 1 yuan.
The verbal battle between the two sides can be said to be inextricable.
When the law students from law schools all over the country who are organizing to watch the live broadcast saw this, each of them watched it very seriously, and the admiration for lawyer Yuan Xiang in the hearts of these students was like a torrent of water.
Because the other party's lawyer is also very powerful, biting too hard, if it were an ordinary powerful lawyer who went up, he would probably have been confused and asked for a temporary adjournment.
But Yuan Xiang didn't.
Facing each piece of evidence presented by the other party, Yuan Xiang also has evidence that can refute it.
For example, when the lawyers of the European Nuori Pharmaceutical Group said that Liu Yong sold the generic drugs of Asanguo for profit and caused huge losses to their company, Yuan Xiang presented sufficient evidence to prove that Liu Yong was selling the generic drugs of Asanguo. There is no profit when making pharmaceuticals.
"Judge, this is the transaction information of Mr. Liu Yong from the first order transaction with Aburulang Pharmaceutical Factory in the Three Kingdoms. This is the retail price and ex-factory price of generic drugs in the Three Kingdoms collected after our investigation in the Three Kingdoms. Waiting for evidence, we can see from this that Mr. Liu Yong bought 1000 yuan a box from the pharmacy in Asanguo at the beginning, and it was not an act of profit, because the retail price of pharmacies in Asanguo was 2000 yuan a box.”
Yuan Xiang was calm and calm, defending Liu Yong with reason and evidence.
And the defense evidence is listed one after another.
For example, whether Liu Yong has made a profit by purchasing and selling A Sanguo generic drugs, he has also prepared sufficient evidence.
From the beginning when Liu Yong purchased the generic drugs retailed by the Asanguo Pharmacy, and then contacted the generic drugs from the Asanguo Pharmaceutical Factory, Liu Yong never thought about making a profit from the beginning.
He just wants to help domestic patients with chronic myelogenous leukemia buy cheap medicines that they can afford.
Even because the 2000 yuan a box of retail generic drugs in Asan pharmacies is too expensive, some chronic myelogenous leukemia patients from poor families in China cannot afford it, so Liu Yong’s retail generic drugs for this part are therefore lower than The price of the purchase cost, that is, 1000 yuan is sold to patients with chronic myelogenous leukemia.
This means that Liu Yong also posted money in it.
You told me that such a person is reselling drugs for profit?
Subsequently.
When Liu Yong contacted the Abululang pharmaceutical factory in Asanguo, the original ex-factory price of the pharmaceutical factory was 800 yuan a box, but the price Liu Yong sold to domestic patients with chronic myelogenous leukemia was 500 yuan a box.
This fully proves that even if Liu Yong found a pharmaceutical factory channel for generic drugs and was able to buy drugs on a large scale, he did not sell generic drugs to domestic CML patients for profit.
All the evidence of Liu Yong's payment transactions with pharmaceutical factories and domestic patients with chronic myelogenous leukemia are fully displayed.
These evidences were collected by Xu Nuo to assist lawyer Yuan Xiang in China and the Three Kingdoms, and Guan Ju also gave many useful optimization suggestions for this.
With such a sufficient chain of evidence, it can be proved that Liu Yong's sale of Asan generic drugs is not for profit.
"These evidences can show that it is pure nonsense that Mr. Liu Yong said by the European Nori Pharmaceuticals that Mr. Liu Yong sold generic drugs. The price difference reached 32.65 yuan, may I ask the plaintiff, is this what you call profit?"
Lawyer Yuan Xiang's rational and well-founded rebuttal left the other party at a loss.
When everyone in the auditorium saw this, their hearts were immediately boosted with great confidence, because every time an accusation against the European Nori Pharmaceutical Group was refuted, it would be very beneficial to Liu Yong.
At this time, in the lecture hall of the Law School of Yuzhou University of Political Science and Law.
When Teacher Wang saw this, he unscrewed the thermos cup and took a sip of wolfberry soaked water, then looked at the students and said, "Did you see that, if we want to refute the other party's accusation, or accuse the other party, we must To produce sufficient evidence, you have to know what you want to stand in the trial court, and your brother Yuan's calm state like Mount Tai is also worth learning from, you know?"
"Uh-huh!"
"Brother Yuan is too strong!"
"This clear thinking is well-founded!"
"So much detailed and nuanced evidence has been found, which is too strong."
"Brother Yuan is my idol!"
"Keeping a calm state, clear thinking, and being fully prepared are essential tools for a lawyer to go to court."
All the students praised Senior Brother Yuan one after another, and took Senior Brother Yuan as an example.
At this time, the vast number of netizens watching the live broadcast of the court trial also applauded lawyer Yuan Xiang's orderly defense.
"As expected of Lawyer Yuan, you did a great job!"
"Hahahaha, the lawyers of European Norry Pharmaceutical Group have nothing to say."
"Laughing to death, I didn't expect our evidence to be so strong."
"I've said it all, Liu Yong's body is not afraid of the oblique shadow."
"Didn't many people scold Liu Yong for being a drug dealer at the beginning, and they paid hundreds of thousands of dollars to buy medicine for our domestic chronic myelogenous leukemia patients. Is this what you call a drug dealer?"
"This is the God of Medicine!"
"Fuck, Liu Yong is really awesome. If it were me, I would definitely not be able to buy generic medicines for patients like this. At most, I would buy them myself."
"Lawyer Yuan is amazing, didn't you say that Liu Yong was selling fake medicines for profit, and he slapped you all in the face!"
Yuan Xiang's defense of Liu Yong just now can be said to have doubled the confidence of countless netizens who have followed this case.
But in fact this is not the most critical point.
The most important thing is whether the generic drug in Asanguo is a counterfeit drug. After all, whether it is for profit and how much profit, this may involve the influencing factors of how many years Liu Yong will be sentenced if he is sentenced. .
After all, if you are really a drug dealer, the severity of your sentence will definitely be different if you make a profit of 1 yuan from selling counterfeit drugs and [-] million yuan.
After Yuan Xiang defended Liu Yong's non-profit-oriented item, he soon had a verbal battle with the European Nori Pharmaceutical Group on whether to sell fake drugs!
European Norui Pharmaceutical Group is also very smart. After knowing whether it is profitable or not, it can't give a heavy blow, so it firmly bites on Liu Yong's sale of counterfeit medicines and makes a big fuss.
Both sides have had a heated debate on the point of fake drugs.
"This is an appraisal certificate issued by an authoritative biomedical appraisal institution. It compares the ingredients of the generic drug sold by Mr. Liu Yong and the imatinib drug of the European Nuorui Pharmaceutical Group."
Yuan Xiang also produced relevant evidence.
"The test results show that the drug sold by Mr. Liu Yong is 99.99% similar to the European Nuo Rui Pharmaceutical Group in terms of drug composition, efficacy and pharmacology. This is a real drug that is really effective for patients with chronic myeloid leukemia , not some fake medicine!"
Regarding whether or not to sell counterfeit medicines, all Yuan Xiang can do is to work hard on this.
Because if it is calculated according to whether the generic drug of Asan is included in the domestic drug approval list, then the generic drug of Asan is a "fake drug", even if its efficacy is real.
as predicted.
The lawyers of European Nori Pharmaceutical Group grasped this key point.
Therefore, one party used the provisions of the law to define counterfeit medicines as the basis for whether Liu Yong sold counterfeit medicines.
On the other hand, it argues from the efficacy of the drug itself on the disease.
The back and forth between the two sides can be said to be extremely fierce, like a battle, the two sides have fallen into a fierce stalemate, but even so, Yuan Xiang also maintains a calm state of refutation, just like calm and calm on the battlefield military commander.
It wasn't just lawyers for both sides who were arguing fiercely.
Even on the Internet, netizens have discussed a lot.
What are counterfeit medicines?
Is it a counterfeit medicine that has no effect?
Is it a counterfeit medicine to take an effective medicine that can save lives but is illegal?
"Medicine is originally used to save people and treat diseases. It can have a life-saving effect on patients with chronic myelogenous leukemia. It has the same effect as the genuine medicine, so it is the real medicine!"
"If generic drugs are considered real drugs, who will develop real drugs in the future?"
"It's too difficult to define. The lawyers on both sides insist on their own opinions, and they are all reasonable!"
"Actually, the so-called "genuine medicine" stipulated by the provisions is nothing more than the interests of pharmaceutical companies."
"From the essence of medicine, it must be considered real medicine."
"The medicine sold by Liu Yong has saved so many lives, isn't this the real medicine?"
"I think the focus of the debate is not actually this, but whether the medicine is protected by patent copyright."
"The European Nuo Rui Pharmaceutical Group's medicine is the real medicine, but the medicine Liu Yong gave to patients with chronic myelogenous leukemia is also the real medicine, the identification is complete!"
"Fuck, the lawyers on both sides are fighting fiercely. Is this an awesome lawyer!"
"Whether to define counterfeit medicine is actually the key to Liu Yong's judgment of whether he is guilty or not."
#What is counterfeit medicine? #
Popularity value: 2.1 million!
Number of participants in the discussion: 1694 million
Following the debate on the definition of counterfeit medicine by the lawyers of both sides on the live broadcast of the trial, the topic of what constitutes counterfeit medicine has also been heatedly discussed on the Internet, and it is about to turn into a quarrel.
At this time, Xu Nuo, who was sitting in the gallery, couldn't help thinking about a question.
If someone imitates and sells [Ponatinib] developed by your own company, and the drug effect is exactly the same as the real one, is this a counterfeit drug?
Is your company going to sue him?
This kind of association is closely related to the content of the debate between the lawyers of the two sides.
However, Xu Nuo quickly came to his senses and died laughing. It is simply not profitable for others to imitate and sell his company's [Ponatinib], which means that basically such a situation will not happen.
Because the current price of Xynuo's ponatinib is basically the bottom price, but part of the profit is subsidized by the Medical Administration to the company.
However, if others want to imitate production, they must invest in raw materials, production, labor and other costs.
In this way, there is no profit at all, and naturally no one will do it.
Why did the Abrulang pharmaceutical factory in the three countries imitate the imatinib produced by the European Nori Pharmaceutical Group?
It is simply because the international and domestic price of this drug from the European Nori Pharmaceutical Group is too high, and there is a lot of room for profit even if it is sold at a low price after the imitation production by Ah San.
You ask Ah San to imitate Xu Nuo's ponatinib and try it, and you won't be compensated for the underpants!
Because after you imitate the production, if you sell it in China, you must have a lower price than the domestic price to have a chance to sell it. Otherwise, serious people who have cheap genuine medicines will not buy them, and buy you a counterfeit?
So Xu Nuo basically doesn't have to worry about such problems.
What needs to be considered is whether there will be problems with generic drugs when the new drug ponatinib of our company goes abroad and is sold at a price in overseas regions.
However, Xu Nuo’s ponatinib itself has advantages in efficacy and price. In addition, if it is sold in developed regions such as Europe and the United States, their medical insurance is better, so after entering the medical insurance, it may be sold. The price will be relatively low, so that Xu Nuo can also earn money, and the living space of generic drugs is basically compressed to the minimum.
Even if there are generic drugs, I believe patients are more willing to take slightly more expensive genuine drugs.
in court.
With the end of the fierce debate between the two sides, the justice must make a judgment on the definition of "fake medicine".
But this kind of thing is definitely impossible to make a decision immediately after listening to Fang Shuang's statement.
So the judge decided that the court needs to carefully discuss the definition of "counterfeit medicine" in this case in the collegial panel.
During recess.
Yuan Xiang greeted "cordially" with the lawyer representing the European Norin Pharmaceutical Group.
In fact, Liu Jiang, the lawyer of European Nori Pharmaceutical Group, is also very powerful in China. He didn't want to take this case at first, but due to the pressure from the law firm, he had to take this case.
Since he has no choice but to accept the case, no matter what his position is, he will naturally go all out.
Yuan Xiang expressed his understanding on this point.
But the netizens don't know as much as Yuan Xiang. After all, in the eyes of the netizens, the lawyer of the European Nuori Pharmaceutical Group is simply helping the evildoers!
"I thought that European Nori Pharmaceutical Group hired foreign lawyers, but I didn't expect it to be our own lawyers."
"[Picture Information · jpg] This lawyer is called Liu Jiang, everyone remember that he will not ask him to take cases in the future."
"I'm so pissed off, can't we Chinese people unite a bit and not accept the case of European Norry Pharmaceutical Group?"
"There are tens of thousands of lawyers in the world. If you don't answer, others will."
"It is said that this Liu Jiang is also a very powerful lawyer? Is it true? Then why did he become a dog for the European Norry Pharmaceutical Group?"
"Made, this rubbish lawyer is not a human being, is he?"
"At this time, does this lawyer dare to take this case?"
"Seeing that everyone is talking about Liu Jiang, I feel relieved. It's really speechless to help foreign medical capital develop our own medicine god at this time."
"Is there a possibility that Lawyer Liu Jiang can't do anything about it?"
"If you don't take this case, it's over? There's nothing you can do. Could it be that someone is forcing you to take this case with a knife? You're laughing!"
"But any lawyer with a bit of backbone will not act as an attorney for the European Nori Pharmaceutical Group?"
"There are people like this in the world. The gringo gave a lot of money and rushed over to lick it like a dog."
Netizens can be said to be mad at lawyer Liu Jiang, and many people even dug up the cases that lawyer Liu Jiang has represented in the past, and found that this lawyer is actually quite a good person.
Why is it that at this time, the late festival is not guaranteed, and you are acting as a lawyer for the European Nurui Pharmaceutical Group?
It's really puzzling!
Lawyer Yuan Xiang also appealed after learning that netizens abused and attacked Lawyer Liu Jiang, asking all netizens to pay attention to the case itself as much as possible and not to personally attack the attorney.
Xu Nuo felt that the other party's lawyer was quite capable.
However, I have already hired Yuan Xiang as an attorney for Liu Yong, and if the defense of this case goes well, Xu Nuo plans to invite Yuan Xiang to come to my company as a legal consultant.
It depends on whether Yuan Xiang is willing to come. After all, with his current status, he basically picks the legal advisors of the world's top companies at random.
And although my company has started to grow bigger and stronger now, it still needs some time and effort to become a large enterprise of the global top level.
"Boss, will the judge sentence Mr. Liu Yong after the court session continues later?"
The assistant Wen Ruohan sitting next to Xu Nuo suddenly asked worriedly.
Because the last point about the "counterfeit medicine" was basically evenly matched, and Yuan Xiang's lawyer didn't see any big advantage, so Wen Ruohan couldn't be sure whether Liu Yong would be found not guilty or guilty.
"I can't say for sure. The justices are collaborating at the moment, and the court will be very cautious about defining 'fake medicine'."
Xu Nuo shook his head and said.
At this moment, no one knows what kind of judgment the trial court will make.
"what"
Wen Ruohan couldn't help frowning.
"Sometimes, it's not just as simple as guilt or innocence."
At this time, Professor Huang Wenqiang next to him suddenly said seriously.
As the head of the biomedical laboratory team of Xu Nuo Company, he has his own analysis of this case: "I feel that the court should not easily make a conclusion of guilt or innocence in this trial. The court needs to consider The majesty of the law and the warmth of humanity."
"Professor Huang, do you mean that the trial court may choose to maintain the majesty of the law without imposing any substantive punishment on Liu Yong?"
After Xu Nuo heard the words, he couldn't help but think of this.
indeed.
Just now everyone was wondering whether Liu Yong was guilty or not, and whether the medicine he sold was fake or genuine.
But everyone may have overlooked one point, that is, judging from the current domestic legal provisions, Liu Yong has indeed committed a crime. If he is not guilty, then it is very likely that counterfeit drugs will be everywhere in the future.
If convicted and sentenced to prison, it will undoubtedly chill the hearts of many, many people.
After all, Liu Yong purchased and smuggled the Asan generic drug for domestic patients with chronic myelogenous leukemia. If Liu Yong really went to prison, this case might not have typical significance.
In this way, there is a compromise.
Then probation.
This is what Professor Huang said, there will be no substantive punishment, because if Liu Yong is sentenced to probation, Liu Yong will not have to go to prison to serve his sentence.
Of course, this is just a compromise, Xu Nuo naturally hopes that Liu Yong can have the same ending as the prototype character on Earth in his previous life.
That ending is the most ideal, because the archetypal character on Earth was innocent in the end, and the prosecution withdrew the prosecution against the archetypal character.
As for whether this parallel world will end like this, Xu Nuo doesn't know.
Even if it is not the ending on the original earth, as Professor Huang Wenqiang said, there will be no substantial prison sentence, it is still a pretty good result, at least everyone can accept it.
In fact, Xu Nuo thinks the possibility of this result is quite high.
Because Liu Yong’s selling generic drugs, illegal purchasing, smuggling, etc. are more or less illegal, and it is really difficult to distinguish between genuine and counterfeit drugs.
Then Liu Yong’s essential purpose of selling Asan generic drugs is not for self-profit, but to save domestic chronic myelogenous leukemia patients. The starting point itself is good.
And it has truly saved the lives of countless patients with chronic myelogenous leukemia.
"If the true and false medicines cannot be clearly defined, a suspended sentence should be the best way."
Professor Huang Wenqiang nodded and said.
Xu Nuo couldn't help looking at Professor Huang Wenqiang, thinking, good guy, you are an expert in the field of biomedicine, and you know a lot about the law.
As a result, you only know when you ask.
Professor Huang Wenqiang has a son who works in the Political and Legal Affairs Bureau.
After the adjournment ends.
The trial continued, and at that time the attorneys for both parties had finished arguing on the aspects that should be argued.
The justices asked the parties to make final arguments.
There is no doubt that the European Nori Pharmaceutical Group will convict Liu Yong on the basis of "selling counterfeit medicines" and the definition of "counterfeit medicines" in domestic laws and regulations.
Lawyer Yuan Xiang knew that it would not be very meaningful to argue too much here.
So lawyer Yuan Xiang told again with great emotion the reason and purpose of Liu Yong's illegal purchasing, smuggling, and selling of Asan generic drugs, as well as the impact it caused.
As Xu Nuo thought just now when the court was adjourned, lawyer Yuan Xiang emphasized that Liu Yong did not sell the generic Asan drug for profit, and used the money to buy medicine for domestic patients with chronic myelogenous leukemia.
Secondly, Liu Yong's move has saved countless chronic myelogenous leukemia patients and their families, and has had a positive impact on society.
After speaking, lawyer Yuan Xiang only said: "I hope the court can consider it comprehensively."
Xu Nuo could tell that lawyer Yuan Xiang also wanted to win Liu Yong's innocence at the beginning, but it seemed a little difficult now. The court had to consider maintaining the majesty of the law, and then also had to consider the facts stated by lawyer Yuan Xiang.
From the atmosphere at the scene, it can be seen that Liu Yong's case should have gradually become clear in today's trial. There is a high probability of guilt, and it depends on how the judge decides.
If the sentence is unreasonable, many people will be unwilling!
"It seems that the sentence may be suspended."
Xu Nuo took a deep breath and muttered.
At this time, the majority of netizens who watched the live broadcast gradually saw the situation clearly, and it might be a bit difficult to be innocent, so everyone said, you should judge the judge, and you will get the meaning.
"I think if there is a sentence, it should be a few months. It just so happens that Liu Yong has been detained for a few months. Basically, he can be released after the sentence. In this way, everyone will be happy."
"I feel that the probability of acquittal on the spot is relatively small."
"Indeed, it is difficult to determine whether to sell counterfeit medicines or not. You can see how many rounds of heated debates the lawyers of both sides have had."
"At this time, it is necessary to reflect the majesty of the law and the warmth of humanity."
"I feel that the judge is very difficult to handle. It is really difficult to grasp!"
"@大法律, everyone is watching, anyway, you can figure it out."
"Just make sense."
"Can you really sentence him to three to five years?"
"Aren't we used to the rubbish European Nori Pharmaceutical Group!"
finally.
The court pronounced a verdict on Liu Yong's case.
Sure enough, Xu Nuo and Professor Huang Wenqiang expected.
The judge finally chose a sentence that not only upheld the majesty of the law, but also showed the warmth of humanity.
That is to say, Liu Yong was sentenced to one year's imprisonment and one year's probation for his crimes of selling generic drugs, illegal purchasing, and smuggling.
The court representatives of European Norry Pharmaceutical Group were very angry when they saw such a penalty.
Because of their previous preparations, they are very confident that Liu Yong will be sent to jail, because according to domestic regulations, imported drugs that have not been approved by the Department of Medicine are counterfeit drugs in the legal sense!
"Yes, this penalty is not bad."
"Hahaha, I knew it would be impossible for Liu Yong to go to jail."
"It's okay, the majesty is maintained, and the warmth of humanity is also reflected."
"If you don't understand, just ask, what does it mean to be sentenced to one year in prison and suspended for one year?"
"Don't you need to go to jail?"
"After all, it was still sentenced, but the result is already very good."
"Norui Pharmaceutical Group Europe is in a hurry, he is in a hurry!"
"I think this is very good. I didn't open Liu Yong's network because of public opinion, but considering Liu Yong's behavior is positive, he was given a suspended sentence. As a netizen said before, both majesty and warmth are fully displayed. out."
When the trial court in Yuzhou pronounced the verdict on Liu Yong's case, many viewers who watched the live broadcast of the trial were quite able to accept the result.
For Liu Yong, lawyer Yuan Xiang, Xu Nuo and others, such a result is also within the acceptable range.
Because if Liu Yong had a one-year probation, he would basically not be in jail, and after the one-year probation ended, he, as the "medicine god" and "hero" in people's minds, would basically not be used in the days to come. worried.
After Liu Yong's case was pronounced.
They made the headlines of major domestic news media in no time!
PS: [-] updates today, the second update may be later.
(End of this chapter)
The car escorting Liu Yong slowed down by a gear under the driver's operation, and slowly drove forward on the wide road in front of the trial court.
Both sides of the road.
Crowds of CML patients wearing masks stopped and looked at the escort vehicle.
The elderly, middle-aged men and women, teenagers, and children in the crowd, each of them looked so pure at the moment, and each of them was looking forward to Liu Yong's happy ending today.
When the escort vehicle slowly passed by.
Every chronic myelogenous leukemia patient present took off their masks, and they paid tribute to Liu Yong, the "God of Medicine", with their most sincere feelings.
The bailiff Xiao Li sitting in the escort car was also very sad, but also very moved.
The warmth of human nature warmed the hearts of many people at this moment. Marshal Xiao Li was very pleased that these CML patients who had been rescued by Liu Yong did not forget him and came to support Liu Yong on this very important day.
As the escort vehicle slowly drove to the gate of the Yuzhou Trial Court, the media reporters on the scene did not swarm up to film and report as usual, but at an appropriate distance, they reported to netizens and netizens who were concerned about Liu Yong's incident across the country. The audience introduced the situation at the scene.
And at this time at the gate of the trial court.
In addition to Xu Nuo and Liu Yong's attorney Yuan Xiang, there are also Professor Huang Wenqiang from the research and development team of the domestic new drug [Ponatinib], Xu Zheng, Tan Jia, Zhang Yu, Yang Jiuming from the crew of "I'm Not the God of Medicine", etc. The main actors and many crew members are here.
"Mr. Xu, I'll go there first."
Seeing that Liu Yong had been escorted over, Yuan Xiang told Xu Nuo.
"Uh-huh."
Xu Nuo nodded.
He knew that Yuan Xiang had to make some preparations at this time, and when the trial started later, he would act as Liu Yong's attorney to defend in court.
This time, the opponent is Liu Jiang, the attorney representing the European Nori Pharmaceutical Group.
Although the imatinib of European Nori Pharmaceutical Group has quietly withdrawn from the domestic market, in fact, it was forced to withdraw because no domestic patients bought their drug anymore.
But the European Nuori Pharmaceutical Group is still not reconciled.
The market is gone, and they can't swallow this breath, so they want to work on the Liu Yong incident. Simply put, they want to disgust people and send Liu Yong to jail.
Therefore, European Nori Pharmaceutical Group sued Liu Yong to the court for selling counterfeit drugs and other charges.
Nowadays.
It is an open trial of the Liu Yong case open to the public, and the entire trial will be broadcast live to the public.
Since this case is very special and highly concerned, it has a certain educational and learning significance, and it may play a role in promoting the construction of the rule of law.
For this reason, the Political and Legal Affairs Bureau of Yuzhou also specially organized a live broadcast of the various departments under its jurisdiction. In addition, colleges and universities such as Yuzhou University of Political Science and Law also organized students to watch today's trial of Liu Yong's case.
"Everyone should read carefully and analyze carefully. Who is Liu Yong's attorney? I don't think I need to say more, right?"
Teacher Wang from the law school paced back and forth on the podium of the lecture theater, speaking slowly to the students present.
"It's Senior Brother Yuan!"
"Brother Yuan is awesome!"
"Mr. Wang, will the Liu Yong case be included in our legal textbooks?"
"Mr. Wang, I don't think Liu Yong's case can be judged with just cold laws."
"But judging from the current situation, Liu Yong has indeed committed a crime."
The students below immediately started talking.
"Whether it can be included in the textbook depends on how the sentence will be judged today. Two days ago, your Senior Brother Yuan had a phone call with me. He said that he would defend Liu Yong from multiple perspectives. What about Xiao Yuan? Brothers of yours, you all have to learn how others act as defense lawyers in court, understand?"
Teacher Wang shook his head, and at the same time used Yuan Xiang, a barrister who went abroad from Yuzhou University of Political Science and Law, to educate these law students who are still in school.
"Know it!"
All the students answered in unison.
In fact, regarding the Liu Yong incident, since Liu Yong was arrested, the law students in the school have not stopped discussing this case, because on the one hand, Liu Yong has indeed committed a crime in terms of legal provisions, but On the other hand, Liu Yong's actions have indeed greatly helped patients with chronic myeloid leukemia, and it can be said that they have saved the lives of many patients with chronic myelogenous leukemia.
A method of illegal behavior was used to save lives, and many law students discussed it. Is this a kind of emergency avoidance?
Because those chronic myelogenous leukemia patients who were saved by Liu Yong couldn't afford the sky-high price of medicines from the European Nori Pharmaceutical Group, and the only thing that could save their lives was the generic medicine of Asan at that time.
Moreover, Liu Yong himself is also a patient with chronic myeloid leukemia. He has eaten up his million-dollar fortune in the past few years, and he has to take generic medicines of Asan in order to survive.
Law students have continued to discuss the Liu Yong incident until today.
When they saw that more and more people paid attention to Liu Yong and his incident, these law students felt extremely gratified in their hearts. Generally, for cases with high attention like this, the penalty is usually All will be cautious.
Now the pressure came to the Yuzhou Trial Court.
In fact, the main focus of the crime committed by Liu Yong is whether he constituted the sale of counterfeit drugs, because the prosecuting party in this case is the European Nori Pharmaceutical Group. After all, the sale of counterfeit drugs has seriously affected the sales of genuine drugs of their pharmaceutical company.
As for illegal purchasing and smuggling, Liu Yong was prosecuted by the prosecutors, but as long as he was found not guilty of selling counterfeit drugs, then taking into account various factors, the prosecution of illegal purchasing and smuggling would be able to comply. Due to the reasonable wishes of the broad masses of the people, no lawsuit was filed against Liu Yong.
Today Yuan Xiang is going to focus on defending Liu Yong in selling counterfeit medicines.
As for illegal purchasing and smuggling, this is secondary.
After Liu Yong was escorted to the trial court, the on-site jurors entered one after another, and more people were waiting outside the court for the result of the trial.
Of course, people can also take out their mobile phones and directly watch the live video broadcast of the trial court to understand the progress in real time.
Today's trial of Liu Yong's case undoubtedly occupied the headlines of the major news pages, and attracted countless netizens to pay close attention to the trend of the trial.
As for the plaintiff Fang Europe Nuo Rui Pharmaceutical Group, whose reputation has already rotted into the ditch, it has already been scolded crazy by netizens at this moment.
"Garbage Europe Nori Pharmaceutical Group, bah!"
"Support Liu Yong!"
"The European Nori Pharmaceutical Group's medicines can't be sold anymore, and now they are still biting about Liu Yong. It's really disgusting."
"@Europe Nuorui Pharmaceutical Group, no one is buying your medicine."
"I'm really glad that Director Xu's company in our country has developed a new drug, otherwise I don't know how arrogant the European Nori Pharmaceutical Group is at the moment!"
"If I were the European Nori Pharmaceutical Group, I would withdraw the lawsuit at this time, and then Liu Yong's illegal purchasing agent and smuggling prosecutors would also withdraw the lawsuit. Wouldn't they be acquitted?"
"@Europe Nuorui Pharmaceutical Group, come out and bark! Where are people?"
"To be honest, if there is no new domestic drug developed by Xu Dao Company, the European Nuo Rui Pharmaceutical Group must be very arrogant at the moment, and domestic patients with chronic myelogenous leukemia still cannot do without their drugs, so it is estimated that Liu Yong will be given a light sentence this time. The probability is much lower.”
"If Liu Yong is sentenced lightly or is not guilty today, Dao Xu's new drug must have contributed!"
"I'm so pissed off at the European Nuori Pharmaceutical Group. If it weren't for this broken company, Liu Yong would have been released a long time ago."
"@Europe Nuorui Pharmaceutical Group, why don't you die, you!"
Netizens have hated this European Nori Pharmaceutical Group for a long time, and now they can't wait to pull it out and spit one by one.
But as many people said, if Xu Nuo's company hadn't developed new drugs, it is estimated that the European Nuo Rui Pharmaceutical Group would be more arrogant at this moment, and then punish Liu Yong to death. After all, Liu Yong was arrested at the time At that time, the director Xu Nuo stood up to speak for Liu Yong, but the result was an arrogant reply from the European Nori Pharmaceutical Group.
Only now.
When there are already very low-priced domestically produced new drugs in the country, the European Nuori Pharmaceutical Group has already dared not release another one.
Because there is no room for them to survive in the field of chronic myelogenous leukemia drugs, at this moment the European Norry Pharmaceutical Group can only look forward to being able to sue Liu Yong and give Liu Yong a sentence.
Netizens thought at the beginning that the European Nuori Pharmaceutical Group did not dare to come out arrogantly and force Lai Lai.
Only found out later.
Good guy, it turns out that the major social media platforms have already banned the European Nori Pharmaceutical Group, and severely authorized a wave.
The scene of the trial.
Xu Nuo, his assistant Wen Ruohan, Professor Huang Wenqiang, the R&D team of the new domestic drug ponatinib, and the main actors of "I'm Not the God of Medicine" sat in the front of the auditorium.
A small number of patients with chronic myelogenous leukemia also came to the auditorium.
After all, the group of patients with chronic myelogenous leukemia is too large, and it is impossible for everyone to come to the auditorium to listen, so a small number of people were selected to come.
In addition, many well-known and upright people from the media, legal circles, and medical circles also came to the auditorium. After all, this is a case that almost everyone pays attention to.
After a while, the trial officially began.
The plaintiff and the defendant had a heated debate on whether Liu Yong sold counterfeit medicines. Yuan Xiang is worthy of being a well-known barrister in China. Facing the pressure of the European Norry Pharmaceutical Group, he was not at all panicked. Take it easy every step of the way.
Whenever the plaintiff accused Liu Yong of selling counterfeit drugs from a tricky point of view, Yuan Xiang could defend with ease.
However, the European Nuori Pharmaceutical Group is killing them all. Liu Yong’s sale of counterfeit drugs has seriously affected the sales of their genuine drugs during that period, and before and after the emergence of Asan generic drugs, the European Nuori Pharmaceutical Group’s drug imatinib Ni's sales curve and data are listed.
Yuan Xiang defended the drug on the grounds of the unreasonable pricing of drugs by the European Nori Pharmaceutical Group itself and the double standards at home and abroad.
That's exactly what happened.
The price of the drug imatinib was originally priced by the European Nori Pharmaceutical Group, which was seriously unreasonable when compared with domestic and foreign regions.
Because they sell a box of medicine for 24000 yuan in China, and even raised the price to 27000 yuan after Liu Yong was arrested.
The price of this drug abroad is about 1 yuan.
The verbal battle between the two sides can be said to be inextricable.
When the law students from law schools all over the country who are organizing to watch the live broadcast saw this, each of them watched it very seriously, and the admiration for lawyer Yuan Xiang in the hearts of these students was like a torrent of water.
Because the other party's lawyer is also very powerful, biting too hard, if it were an ordinary powerful lawyer who went up, he would probably have been confused and asked for a temporary adjournment.
But Yuan Xiang didn't.
Facing each piece of evidence presented by the other party, Yuan Xiang also has evidence that can refute it.
For example, when the lawyers of the European Nuori Pharmaceutical Group said that Liu Yong sold the generic drugs of Asanguo for profit and caused huge losses to their company, Yuan Xiang presented sufficient evidence to prove that Liu Yong was selling the generic drugs of Asanguo. There is no profit when making pharmaceuticals.
"Judge, this is the transaction information of Mr. Liu Yong from the first order transaction with Aburulang Pharmaceutical Factory in the Three Kingdoms. This is the retail price and ex-factory price of generic drugs in the Three Kingdoms collected after our investigation in the Three Kingdoms. Waiting for evidence, we can see from this that Mr. Liu Yong bought 1000 yuan a box from the pharmacy in Asanguo at the beginning, and it was not an act of profit, because the retail price of pharmacies in Asanguo was 2000 yuan a box.”
Yuan Xiang was calm and calm, defending Liu Yong with reason and evidence.
And the defense evidence is listed one after another.
For example, whether Liu Yong has made a profit by purchasing and selling A Sanguo generic drugs, he has also prepared sufficient evidence.
From the beginning when Liu Yong purchased the generic drugs retailed by the Asanguo Pharmacy, and then contacted the generic drugs from the Asanguo Pharmaceutical Factory, Liu Yong never thought about making a profit from the beginning.
He just wants to help domestic patients with chronic myelogenous leukemia buy cheap medicines that they can afford.
Even because the 2000 yuan a box of retail generic drugs in Asan pharmacies is too expensive, some chronic myelogenous leukemia patients from poor families in China cannot afford it, so Liu Yong’s retail generic drugs for this part are therefore lower than The price of the purchase cost, that is, 1000 yuan is sold to patients with chronic myelogenous leukemia.
This means that Liu Yong also posted money in it.
You told me that such a person is reselling drugs for profit?
Subsequently.
When Liu Yong contacted the Abululang pharmaceutical factory in Asanguo, the original ex-factory price of the pharmaceutical factory was 800 yuan a box, but the price Liu Yong sold to domestic patients with chronic myelogenous leukemia was 500 yuan a box.
This fully proves that even if Liu Yong found a pharmaceutical factory channel for generic drugs and was able to buy drugs on a large scale, he did not sell generic drugs to domestic CML patients for profit.
All the evidence of Liu Yong's payment transactions with pharmaceutical factories and domestic patients with chronic myelogenous leukemia are fully displayed.
These evidences were collected by Xu Nuo to assist lawyer Yuan Xiang in China and the Three Kingdoms, and Guan Ju also gave many useful optimization suggestions for this.
With such a sufficient chain of evidence, it can be proved that Liu Yong's sale of Asan generic drugs is not for profit.
"These evidences can show that it is pure nonsense that Mr. Liu Yong said by the European Nori Pharmaceuticals that Mr. Liu Yong sold generic drugs. The price difference reached 32.65 yuan, may I ask the plaintiff, is this what you call profit?"
Lawyer Yuan Xiang's rational and well-founded rebuttal left the other party at a loss.
When everyone in the auditorium saw this, their hearts were immediately boosted with great confidence, because every time an accusation against the European Nori Pharmaceutical Group was refuted, it would be very beneficial to Liu Yong.
At this time, in the lecture hall of the Law School of Yuzhou University of Political Science and Law.
When Teacher Wang saw this, he unscrewed the thermos cup and took a sip of wolfberry soaked water, then looked at the students and said, "Did you see that, if we want to refute the other party's accusation, or accuse the other party, we must To produce sufficient evidence, you have to know what you want to stand in the trial court, and your brother Yuan's calm state like Mount Tai is also worth learning from, you know?"
"Uh-huh!"
"Brother Yuan is too strong!"
"This clear thinking is well-founded!"
"So much detailed and nuanced evidence has been found, which is too strong."
"Brother Yuan is my idol!"
"Keeping a calm state, clear thinking, and being fully prepared are essential tools for a lawyer to go to court."
All the students praised Senior Brother Yuan one after another, and took Senior Brother Yuan as an example.
At this time, the vast number of netizens watching the live broadcast of the court trial also applauded lawyer Yuan Xiang's orderly defense.
"As expected of Lawyer Yuan, you did a great job!"
"Hahahaha, the lawyers of European Norry Pharmaceutical Group have nothing to say."
"Laughing to death, I didn't expect our evidence to be so strong."
"I've said it all, Liu Yong's body is not afraid of the oblique shadow."
"Didn't many people scold Liu Yong for being a drug dealer at the beginning, and they paid hundreds of thousands of dollars to buy medicine for our domestic chronic myelogenous leukemia patients. Is this what you call a drug dealer?"
"This is the God of Medicine!"
"Fuck, Liu Yong is really awesome. If it were me, I would definitely not be able to buy generic medicines for patients like this. At most, I would buy them myself."
"Lawyer Yuan is amazing, didn't you say that Liu Yong was selling fake medicines for profit, and he slapped you all in the face!"
Yuan Xiang's defense of Liu Yong just now can be said to have doubled the confidence of countless netizens who have followed this case.
But in fact this is not the most critical point.
The most important thing is whether the generic drug in Asanguo is a counterfeit drug. After all, whether it is for profit and how much profit, this may involve the influencing factors of how many years Liu Yong will be sentenced if he is sentenced. .
After all, if you are really a drug dealer, the severity of your sentence will definitely be different if you make a profit of 1 yuan from selling counterfeit drugs and [-] million yuan.
After Yuan Xiang defended Liu Yong's non-profit-oriented item, he soon had a verbal battle with the European Nori Pharmaceutical Group on whether to sell fake drugs!
European Norui Pharmaceutical Group is also very smart. After knowing whether it is profitable or not, it can't give a heavy blow, so it firmly bites on Liu Yong's sale of counterfeit medicines and makes a big fuss.
Both sides have had a heated debate on the point of fake drugs.
"This is an appraisal certificate issued by an authoritative biomedical appraisal institution. It compares the ingredients of the generic drug sold by Mr. Liu Yong and the imatinib drug of the European Nuorui Pharmaceutical Group."
Yuan Xiang also produced relevant evidence.
"The test results show that the drug sold by Mr. Liu Yong is 99.99% similar to the European Nuo Rui Pharmaceutical Group in terms of drug composition, efficacy and pharmacology. This is a real drug that is really effective for patients with chronic myeloid leukemia , not some fake medicine!"
Regarding whether or not to sell counterfeit medicines, all Yuan Xiang can do is to work hard on this.
Because if it is calculated according to whether the generic drug of Asan is included in the domestic drug approval list, then the generic drug of Asan is a "fake drug", even if its efficacy is real.
as predicted.
The lawyers of European Nori Pharmaceutical Group grasped this key point.
Therefore, one party used the provisions of the law to define counterfeit medicines as the basis for whether Liu Yong sold counterfeit medicines.
On the other hand, it argues from the efficacy of the drug itself on the disease.
The back and forth between the two sides can be said to be extremely fierce, like a battle, the two sides have fallen into a fierce stalemate, but even so, Yuan Xiang also maintains a calm state of refutation, just like calm and calm on the battlefield military commander.
It wasn't just lawyers for both sides who were arguing fiercely.
Even on the Internet, netizens have discussed a lot.
What are counterfeit medicines?
Is it a counterfeit medicine that has no effect?
Is it a counterfeit medicine to take an effective medicine that can save lives but is illegal?
"Medicine is originally used to save people and treat diseases. It can have a life-saving effect on patients with chronic myelogenous leukemia. It has the same effect as the genuine medicine, so it is the real medicine!"
"If generic drugs are considered real drugs, who will develop real drugs in the future?"
"It's too difficult to define. The lawyers on both sides insist on their own opinions, and they are all reasonable!"
"Actually, the so-called "genuine medicine" stipulated by the provisions is nothing more than the interests of pharmaceutical companies."
"From the essence of medicine, it must be considered real medicine."
"The medicine sold by Liu Yong has saved so many lives, isn't this the real medicine?"
"I think the focus of the debate is not actually this, but whether the medicine is protected by patent copyright."
"The European Nuo Rui Pharmaceutical Group's medicine is the real medicine, but the medicine Liu Yong gave to patients with chronic myelogenous leukemia is also the real medicine, the identification is complete!"
"Fuck, the lawyers on both sides are fighting fiercely. Is this an awesome lawyer!"
"Whether to define counterfeit medicine is actually the key to Liu Yong's judgment of whether he is guilty or not."
#What is counterfeit medicine? #
Popularity value: 2.1 million!
Number of participants in the discussion: 1694 million
Following the debate on the definition of counterfeit medicine by the lawyers of both sides on the live broadcast of the trial, the topic of what constitutes counterfeit medicine has also been heatedly discussed on the Internet, and it is about to turn into a quarrel.
At this time, Xu Nuo, who was sitting in the gallery, couldn't help thinking about a question.
If someone imitates and sells [Ponatinib] developed by your own company, and the drug effect is exactly the same as the real one, is this a counterfeit drug?
Is your company going to sue him?
This kind of association is closely related to the content of the debate between the lawyers of the two sides.
However, Xu Nuo quickly came to his senses and died laughing. It is simply not profitable for others to imitate and sell his company's [Ponatinib], which means that basically such a situation will not happen.
Because the current price of Xynuo's ponatinib is basically the bottom price, but part of the profit is subsidized by the Medical Administration to the company.
However, if others want to imitate production, they must invest in raw materials, production, labor and other costs.
In this way, there is no profit at all, and naturally no one will do it.
Why did the Abrulang pharmaceutical factory in the three countries imitate the imatinib produced by the European Nori Pharmaceutical Group?
It is simply because the international and domestic price of this drug from the European Nori Pharmaceutical Group is too high, and there is a lot of room for profit even if it is sold at a low price after the imitation production by Ah San.
You ask Ah San to imitate Xu Nuo's ponatinib and try it, and you won't be compensated for the underpants!
Because after you imitate the production, if you sell it in China, you must have a lower price than the domestic price to have a chance to sell it. Otherwise, serious people who have cheap genuine medicines will not buy them, and buy you a counterfeit?
So Xu Nuo basically doesn't have to worry about such problems.
What needs to be considered is whether there will be problems with generic drugs when the new drug ponatinib of our company goes abroad and is sold at a price in overseas regions.
However, Xu Nuo’s ponatinib itself has advantages in efficacy and price. In addition, if it is sold in developed regions such as Europe and the United States, their medical insurance is better, so after entering the medical insurance, it may be sold. The price will be relatively low, so that Xu Nuo can also earn money, and the living space of generic drugs is basically compressed to the minimum.
Even if there are generic drugs, I believe patients are more willing to take slightly more expensive genuine drugs.
in court.
With the end of the fierce debate between the two sides, the justice must make a judgment on the definition of "fake medicine".
But this kind of thing is definitely impossible to make a decision immediately after listening to Fang Shuang's statement.
So the judge decided that the court needs to carefully discuss the definition of "counterfeit medicine" in this case in the collegial panel.
During recess.
Yuan Xiang greeted "cordially" with the lawyer representing the European Norin Pharmaceutical Group.
In fact, Liu Jiang, the lawyer of European Nori Pharmaceutical Group, is also very powerful in China. He didn't want to take this case at first, but due to the pressure from the law firm, he had to take this case.
Since he has no choice but to accept the case, no matter what his position is, he will naturally go all out.
Yuan Xiang expressed his understanding on this point.
But the netizens don't know as much as Yuan Xiang. After all, in the eyes of the netizens, the lawyer of the European Nuori Pharmaceutical Group is simply helping the evildoers!
"I thought that European Nori Pharmaceutical Group hired foreign lawyers, but I didn't expect it to be our own lawyers."
"[Picture Information · jpg] This lawyer is called Liu Jiang, everyone remember that he will not ask him to take cases in the future."
"I'm so pissed off, can't we Chinese people unite a bit and not accept the case of European Norry Pharmaceutical Group?"
"There are tens of thousands of lawyers in the world. If you don't answer, others will."
"It is said that this Liu Jiang is also a very powerful lawyer? Is it true? Then why did he become a dog for the European Norry Pharmaceutical Group?"
"Made, this rubbish lawyer is not a human being, is he?"
"At this time, does this lawyer dare to take this case?"
"Seeing that everyone is talking about Liu Jiang, I feel relieved. It's really speechless to help foreign medical capital develop our own medicine god at this time."
"Is there a possibility that Lawyer Liu Jiang can't do anything about it?"
"If you don't take this case, it's over? There's nothing you can do. Could it be that someone is forcing you to take this case with a knife? You're laughing!"
"But any lawyer with a bit of backbone will not act as an attorney for the European Nori Pharmaceutical Group?"
"There are people like this in the world. The gringo gave a lot of money and rushed over to lick it like a dog."
Netizens can be said to be mad at lawyer Liu Jiang, and many people even dug up the cases that lawyer Liu Jiang has represented in the past, and found that this lawyer is actually quite a good person.
Why is it that at this time, the late festival is not guaranteed, and you are acting as a lawyer for the European Nurui Pharmaceutical Group?
It's really puzzling!
Lawyer Yuan Xiang also appealed after learning that netizens abused and attacked Lawyer Liu Jiang, asking all netizens to pay attention to the case itself as much as possible and not to personally attack the attorney.
Xu Nuo felt that the other party's lawyer was quite capable.
However, I have already hired Yuan Xiang as an attorney for Liu Yong, and if the defense of this case goes well, Xu Nuo plans to invite Yuan Xiang to come to my company as a legal consultant.
It depends on whether Yuan Xiang is willing to come. After all, with his current status, he basically picks the legal advisors of the world's top companies at random.
And although my company has started to grow bigger and stronger now, it still needs some time and effort to become a large enterprise of the global top level.
"Boss, will the judge sentence Mr. Liu Yong after the court session continues later?"
The assistant Wen Ruohan sitting next to Xu Nuo suddenly asked worriedly.
Because the last point about the "counterfeit medicine" was basically evenly matched, and Yuan Xiang's lawyer didn't see any big advantage, so Wen Ruohan couldn't be sure whether Liu Yong would be found not guilty or guilty.
"I can't say for sure. The justices are collaborating at the moment, and the court will be very cautious about defining 'fake medicine'."
Xu Nuo shook his head and said.
At this moment, no one knows what kind of judgment the trial court will make.
"what"
Wen Ruohan couldn't help frowning.
"Sometimes, it's not just as simple as guilt or innocence."
At this time, Professor Huang Wenqiang next to him suddenly said seriously.
As the head of the biomedical laboratory team of Xu Nuo Company, he has his own analysis of this case: "I feel that the court should not easily make a conclusion of guilt or innocence in this trial. The court needs to consider The majesty of the law and the warmth of humanity."
"Professor Huang, do you mean that the trial court may choose to maintain the majesty of the law without imposing any substantive punishment on Liu Yong?"
After Xu Nuo heard the words, he couldn't help but think of this.
indeed.
Just now everyone was wondering whether Liu Yong was guilty or not, and whether the medicine he sold was fake or genuine.
But everyone may have overlooked one point, that is, judging from the current domestic legal provisions, Liu Yong has indeed committed a crime. If he is not guilty, then it is very likely that counterfeit drugs will be everywhere in the future.
If convicted and sentenced to prison, it will undoubtedly chill the hearts of many, many people.
After all, Liu Yong purchased and smuggled the Asan generic drug for domestic patients with chronic myelogenous leukemia. If Liu Yong really went to prison, this case might not have typical significance.
In this way, there is a compromise.
Then probation.
This is what Professor Huang said, there will be no substantive punishment, because if Liu Yong is sentenced to probation, Liu Yong will not have to go to prison to serve his sentence.
Of course, this is just a compromise, Xu Nuo naturally hopes that Liu Yong can have the same ending as the prototype character on Earth in his previous life.
That ending is the most ideal, because the archetypal character on Earth was innocent in the end, and the prosecution withdrew the prosecution against the archetypal character.
As for whether this parallel world will end like this, Xu Nuo doesn't know.
Even if it is not the ending on the original earth, as Professor Huang Wenqiang said, there will be no substantial prison sentence, it is still a pretty good result, at least everyone can accept it.
In fact, Xu Nuo thinks the possibility of this result is quite high.
Because Liu Yong’s selling generic drugs, illegal purchasing, smuggling, etc. are more or less illegal, and it is really difficult to distinguish between genuine and counterfeit drugs.
Then Liu Yong’s essential purpose of selling Asan generic drugs is not for self-profit, but to save domestic chronic myelogenous leukemia patients. The starting point itself is good.
And it has truly saved the lives of countless patients with chronic myelogenous leukemia.
"If the true and false medicines cannot be clearly defined, a suspended sentence should be the best way."
Professor Huang Wenqiang nodded and said.
Xu Nuo couldn't help looking at Professor Huang Wenqiang, thinking, good guy, you are an expert in the field of biomedicine, and you know a lot about the law.
As a result, you only know when you ask.
Professor Huang Wenqiang has a son who works in the Political and Legal Affairs Bureau.
After the adjournment ends.
The trial continued, and at that time the attorneys for both parties had finished arguing on the aspects that should be argued.
The justices asked the parties to make final arguments.
There is no doubt that the European Nori Pharmaceutical Group will convict Liu Yong on the basis of "selling counterfeit medicines" and the definition of "counterfeit medicines" in domestic laws and regulations.
Lawyer Yuan Xiang knew that it would not be very meaningful to argue too much here.
So lawyer Yuan Xiang told again with great emotion the reason and purpose of Liu Yong's illegal purchasing, smuggling, and selling of Asan generic drugs, as well as the impact it caused.
As Xu Nuo thought just now when the court was adjourned, lawyer Yuan Xiang emphasized that Liu Yong did not sell the generic Asan drug for profit, and used the money to buy medicine for domestic patients with chronic myelogenous leukemia.
Secondly, Liu Yong's move has saved countless chronic myelogenous leukemia patients and their families, and has had a positive impact on society.
After speaking, lawyer Yuan Xiang only said: "I hope the court can consider it comprehensively."
Xu Nuo could tell that lawyer Yuan Xiang also wanted to win Liu Yong's innocence at the beginning, but it seemed a little difficult now. The court had to consider maintaining the majesty of the law, and then also had to consider the facts stated by lawyer Yuan Xiang.
From the atmosphere at the scene, it can be seen that Liu Yong's case should have gradually become clear in today's trial. There is a high probability of guilt, and it depends on how the judge decides.
If the sentence is unreasonable, many people will be unwilling!
"It seems that the sentence may be suspended."
Xu Nuo took a deep breath and muttered.
At this time, the majority of netizens who watched the live broadcast gradually saw the situation clearly, and it might be a bit difficult to be innocent, so everyone said, you should judge the judge, and you will get the meaning.
"I think if there is a sentence, it should be a few months. It just so happens that Liu Yong has been detained for a few months. Basically, he can be released after the sentence. In this way, everyone will be happy."
"I feel that the probability of acquittal on the spot is relatively small."
"Indeed, it is difficult to determine whether to sell counterfeit medicines or not. You can see how many rounds of heated debates the lawyers of both sides have had."
"At this time, it is necessary to reflect the majesty of the law and the warmth of humanity."
"I feel that the judge is very difficult to handle. It is really difficult to grasp!"
"@大法律, everyone is watching, anyway, you can figure it out."
"Just make sense."
"Can you really sentence him to three to five years?"
"Aren't we used to the rubbish European Nori Pharmaceutical Group!"
finally.
The court pronounced a verdict on Liu Yong's case.
Sure enough, Xu Nuo and Professor Huang Wenqiang expected.
The judge finally chose a sentence that not only upheld the majesty of the law, but also showed the warmth of humanity.
That is to say, Liu Yong was sentenced to one year's imprisonment and one year's probation for his crimes of selling generic drugs, illegal purchasing, and smuggling.
The court representatives of European Norry Pharmaceutical Group were very angry when they saw such a penalty.
Because of their previous preparations, they are very confident that Liu Yong will be sent to jail, because according to domestic regulations, imported drugs that have not been approved by the Department of Medicine are counterfeit drugs in the legal sense!
"Yes, this penalty is not bad."
"Hahaha, I knew it would be impossible for Liu Yong to go to jail."
"It's okay, the majesty is maintained, and the warmth of humanity is also reflected."
"If you don't understand, just ask, what does it mean to be sentenced to one year in prison and suspended for one year?"
"Don't you need to go to jail?"
"After all, it was still sentenced, but the result is already very good."
"Norui Pharmaceutical Group Europe is in a hurry, he is in a hurry!"
"I think this is very good. I didn't open Liu Yong's network because of public opinion, but considering Liu Yong's behavior is positive, he was given a suspended sentence. As a netizen said before, both majesty and warmth are fully displayed. out."
When the trial court in Yuzhou pronounced the verdict on Liu Yong's case, many viewers who watched the live broadcast of the trial were quite able to accept the result.
For Liu Yong, lawyer Yuan Xiang, Xu Nuo and others, such a result is also within the acceptable range.
Because if Liu Yong had a one-year probation, he would basically not be in jail, and after the one-year probation ended, he, as the "medicine god" and "hero" in people's minds, would basically not be used in the days to come. worried.
After Liu Yong's case was pronounced.
They made the headlines of major domestic news media in no time!
PS: [-] updates today, the second update may be later.
(End of this chapter)
You'll Also Like
-
The Daily Life of the Daughter of a Minor Official
Chapter 185 59 minute ago -
Douluo: My diary has caused Tang San to rebel against his family
Chapter 117 4 hours ago -
Konoha's entry is ninja!
Chapter 195 4 hours ago -
Gao Wu: Infinite killing, full-level talent at the beginning!
Chapter 213 4 hours ago -
Running wild in the arms of the sick boss
Chapter 302 4 hours ago -
Survival in the End of the World: I can summon the undead army
Chapter 230 4 hours ago -
Collection of Chinese Classics: I broadcast history live and talk to the past and present
Chapter 71 4 hours ago -
Pokémon starts with binding the Dragon God system
Chapter 214 4 hours ago -
The famous criminal in Conan's world
Chapter 97 4 hours ago -
Cultivation starts with taming beasts
Chapter 203 4 hours ago