Konoha Ninja World, accept the gang fight of Uchiha justice

Chapter 319 Miscellaneous Talk: Naruto's Politics and Philosophy

Everyone relies on and is bound by his own knowledge and understanding, and calls this reality, but knowledge and understanding are very vague things, and that reality may be nothing but an illusion.People are living in a sense of self, don't you think so?Which of the following sentences is closest to the philosophy embodied in this passage!

A. Every moment of human existence is a passive instrument in the hands of necessity
B. The one that suits you is the best, you have to find it yourself, not let others indoctrinate you

C. Philosophers just interpret the world in different ways, the problem is to change the world.

D. Man is the measure of all things, the measure of how beings exist, and the measure of non-existents
It probably means that human beings rely on their own cognition to judge the truth, but the truth of your judgment is only given to you by others based on your cognition, and you just take it for granted.

This sentence comes from what Naruto said to Sasuke when Itachi was exterminated in the early stage of Naruto. Its purpose is to imply that what you see to Sasuke is not necessarily true. For example, Sasuke knew Itachi when he was a child. When the clan was exterminated, he was a bad guy who didn't recognize his relatives. When he told the truth about Danzo coercing Itachi to kill his clansmen through the masked man, he thought Itachi was a good brother who shouldered all the sins and protected himself.

However, Sasuke may be too young to hear the meaning behind the words. He has been running around for revenge, living in the cognition given to him by others, and never thought about why this happened.

Let's take a look at the answer again. The meaning of A probably means that people's cognition is instilled by the outside world. This meaning is similar to Sasuke's situation, lacking his own understanding and objectivity of cognition;
B means that cognition is understood by oneself and does not require external indoctrination. This situation is also extreme and exaggerates the possibility of human beings. In fact, no matter in reality or in comics, external indoctrination is necessary Yes, such as reading in the real world, academic theories of mathematics and science, and the inheritance of forbidden techniques in the Naruto world. If you don’t stand on the shoulders of the predecessors, what future generations can see is extremely limited;
C probably means that the outside world gives you cognition about all this, and you are responsible for changing all of this, the fact is the same. Kaleidoscope Sharingan, or later use the battle of brothers to teach Sasuke what are the functions of Kaleidoscope Sharingan, so that Sasuke can master Kaleidoscope Sharingan when he opens his eyes, and can have more time to develop his own spells (For example, Amaterasu's advanced plus soil life).

The general meaning of D is that people define everything in the world. This kind of statement is too exaggerated. In fact, everyone knows that it is impossible for human beings to define everything in the world. They can only find laws and define them with symbols. Regular, convenient and practical.

To put it simply, Konoha’s high-level policy at the beginning was to make Sasuke’s Sharingan a tool to control Naruto’s Kyuubi, instead of letting Naruto find a way to grow and grow peacefully with Kyuubi—obviously, the former’s The cost is much lower.At that time, no one knew that these two people were reincarnated brothers, so the "encounter" or "increased friendship" between Naruto and Sasuke was of course also a "bond", but in the eyes of politicians, it was all for profit.

Judging from the development of manga and animation, it seems that Naruto is not fully aware, he is a bit like "Happy Man" written by Ye Shengtao:
This layer of curtain is so light that it has no net weight, so thin that it has no material, so dense that there are no gaps, and so bright that it has no barriers.He is surrounded by such a thing, but he himself does not know that he is surrounded by such a thing.He lives his daily life in this veil, feeling happy in everything and happy all the time.He sees everything around him through this layer of curtain, and feels happy everywhere and everything.

However, Naruto in "Bo Ren Biography" seems to know the history of Miyue well, and he is also maintaining a delicate balance with the thinking of a politician.

But this is not the point, but it reminds me of several philosophical propositions I read some time ago. It seems that using the relationship between Naruto and Sasuke to assist in the interpretation of these propositions will help us understand their connotative relationship.

Hegel's master-slave dialectic

For readers, the most direct implication of the "bond" relationship between Naruto and Sasuke is "mutual recognition" and "mutual struggle". In the process of fighting, the essence of each other's existence is recognized. Symmetrical screens, such as the two battles in the Valley of the End, the long psychological monologue of Naruto chasing Sasuke and Sasuke chasing Naruto, and the animation OP screen.

In Hegel's "Phenomenology of Spirit" (translated first) Chapter 4 "The Truth of Self-Determination" says this:

Only when each other recognizes each other, can it be regarded as admitting oneself at the same time.This acknowledgment implies the existence of self-awareness.And if one is an independent consciousness with existence-for-itself as its essence, and the other is a dependent consciousness with life or existence-for-others as its essence, it becomes master and slave.

"Thus the relation of two self-consciousnesses is characterized by the fact that both themselves and each other justify their existence by a life-and-death struggle. They must participate in this life-and-death struggle because they must put their own The conviction that they exist for themselves, both for each other and for themselves, is elevated to the status of objective truth. Freedom can only be attained by risking one's life...

Sean Homer's "Introduction to Lacan" mentioned that this master-slave dialectic will lead the two sides into an endless struggle to the death. The two sides cannot exist without each other, and they cannot really kill each other. Therefore, It has become a very famous Two-dimensional getting along proposition "love each other and kill each other":
if we remember

The specifically mentioned Kakashi and Jilai also taught Sasuke and Naruto the ninjutsu of "killing each other"/"controlling each other"/"restraining each other", whether in terms of attributes or damage, they can A better understanding of what master-slave dialectics is, and a better understanding of why the love and kill model is deeply loved by rotten girls.

It may be difficult for us to accept or agree with the assertion that "the theme of violence/war breeds homosexual culture", but it is not unreasonable-they involve desperate struggle and mutual recognition,
War seems to be a catalyst for the most hidden violence in the concept of gay relationships.The enemy is at once the object of hatred and desire, a possible lover in times of peace, and a sign of a hostile nation.

Deleuze's "The Two Systems of Madness"
Puppet puppeteer.He has certain powers, to manipulate the puppets, and he exerts certain powers over the children.Kleist has written an excellent essay on this subject.We can say that there are three lines there.The puppeteer is not manipulating the puppet according to the actions the figure will assume.He steers his puppet by a vertical line, or he displaces the center of gravity of the puppet, or, more precisely, he makes the puppet light.It's an abstract line at all, not a tangible line, and it won't be as symbolic as a tangible line.This line is moving because it is composed of many stop points like singularities, but these stop points do not destroy the line.There is no binary relationship or correspondence between the vertical drawn-out lines (thus, these lines are also more real) and the concrete movements of the puppet.

Second, there are entirely different kinds of movement: perceptible and representational curves, arms circling themselves, heads tilted.The line is no longer made of singularities, but of flexible segments—one pose, then another.Finally, there is a third line, which is quite a hard link, which corresponds to the story elements presented by the puppet show.The binary relations or correspondences that structuralism tells us may be formed in lines divided into individual links.The puppet master's own power more often appears at the transition point of the two lines, one is the abstract invisible line, and the other is the linking two lines.

Deleuze|Two mad systems_War
The three lines of puppetry mentioned by Deleuze are:

①The prominent lines of appearance, that is, the movements presented by the puppets.These movements complete the story of the puppet show, as if they are alive, have "bonds", are able to interact and understand each other.

②The invisible thread of manipulation, that is, the invisible thread in the hands of the puppeteer. "The connection between the puppet master and the puppet is not directly, but through a series of real threads that do not need to be seen by the audience in front of the stage-even if the thread is faintly visible in front of the stage, the audience watching the puppet show It doesn't seem to be there."

In this way, an interesting dialectic relationship emerges in the marionette show: a false movement, that is, the movement of the puppet is taken as real movement by the audience; and a real movement, that is, the movement of the string, is ignored by the audience intentionally or unintentionally. up.This dialectical relationship is the prerequisite for the establishment of the puppet show.We don't need to understand the movement of the real string, we just need to watch the false movement that underpins the whole narrative and meaning unfolding.

“Master-Slave Dialectics”: It’s not that games are becoming more and more like the world, but that the world is becoming more and more like games – yqqlm
③ The ideological line of the structure, that is, the line of why the puppet master can become a puppet master and the puppet can become a puppet.This thread does not exist physically, but a higher-dimensional structure system, allowing it to become itself in a limited space.

If we substitute in the relationship between Naruto and Sasuke, we can see the existence of these three lines.

①In the process of getting along, the two think/think that it is a fetter established by "self-effort". Whether it is to break up or guard is their own choice. ——The eye exchange of "childhood before reading" added by manga/anime in the middle and late stages seems to be regarded as strengthening this line while diluting other lines.

②However, this is not the case. In the political game of the high-level Konoha, the relationship between the two is considered a dangerous item of "mutual restraint".Sasuke and Naruto's house, Konoha's high-level executives can drive straight into no one's land, and Kakashi even picked up the milk box that Naruto drank wasted and looked at it.Naruto may not be aware that during the entire manga/animation process, he is closely monitored, whether it is the crystal ball of the third generation, Yeluka's care, Kakashi's professor, Jiraiya's company, or Sai The intervention of Yamato, and Yamato's personal protection.The audience will hardly feel the existence of this kind of monitoring during the movie-watching process-unless the author mentions it, they will find out.And Sasuke can be alone for a long time, out of the field of vision (even the field of view of the film) (or writing sharing eyes was used to monitor Kyuubi from the beginning).

③In a higher dimension, Naruto and Sasuke are reincarnated blood, which is the real fundamental and structural reason for them to become a bond.As the reincarnation of Indra and Asura, as the twins arranged to be sacrificed by Heijue (the third son), he accumulated the power to revive Kaguya time and time again in the process of provoking dissension.

If you want to have a more visual observation of the three-wire theory

What we think of as the Oedipus complex seems to be the most direct one of killing one's father and marrying one's mother.

Not quite.

Killing the father and marrying the mother are of course a very important part. In Hokage's Kaguya family myth, the "killed" people are absent or have no more important role.

For example, Kaguya's man is "disposable", the wife of Sage of the Six Paths, Madara and Hashirama's wife, it is difficult for us to recall.If the wife of the Sage of the Six Paths (Yuyi) exerts influence on her son's education, perhaps Heijue will not be able to complete his conspiracy more smoothly.

For example, the mothers who were sealed by the children together, whether it is the cooperation between Hamura and Yuyi, or the cooperation between Naruto and Sasuke—their real mother Otsutsuki Kaguya was not "killed" in the end, but "sealed" .

For example, Heijue's behavior is "marrying his mother". He lives on Huiye's body and continues to carry out the "thousand-year plan" to revive his mother. The relationship of a single entity to a plural group.

In the Oedipus complex, there is actually a very important part: brother killing each other.

After the two sons of Oedipus, Polynices and Eteocles, started to kill each other after driving away their father, they also died at the hands of each other in the end.

The origins of fratricide can even be traced back to the stories of Abel and Cain, and Esau and Jacob.

Bloodlust
Brotherly enmity is an illustration of violence.Twin brothers represent a heightened fraternal rivalry.To think of twins and lookalikes is to think of the threat that arises from similarity, or, as Freud put it, "narcissism for minor differences"—the hostility that arises from small differences.

This similarity will bring extremely strong malice. It is mentioned in "Killing Desire": two similar individuals will be deceptive, the real self will be cancelled, and the duplicate mirror image will be materialized and participate in judgment.William Wilson in Edgar Allan Poe's story even found "people like himself" "an unbearable horror", "a loathsome unity"

Pan Shen mentioned in "Love and Kill with Self - Killing Each Other" that in "Artificial Intelligence AI", David's first violent behavior broke out after seeing a copy of himself

If we incorporate the Oedipus brother killing plot into Hokage, it seems that we can observe a possibility:
Before Naruto and Sasuke were actually companions in the seventh class, there was almost no dialogue between the two—either glaring or fisting—even in the "childhood before reading" screen added later, the two are most The picture of "heart-to-heart connection" is "eye contact". Their physical distance is very far, one is on the riverside runway, and the other is in front of the riverside bench.

(End of this chapter)